Rodgers at safety is a bit funny, but it does not take long to get used to. When I use those big name guys I like to put them in positions where they do not always belong.
It is not easy to use the current guys to recreate old rosters. It is always a judgement call on what to make sure lines up. Do you match experience, height and weight, long hair or short hair? You try to get as close as possible without spending an hour on each players searching for the "perfect" match. So I try to get as close as I can with each area. I would not worry about experience at all, except that in Franchise mode you do not want a guy retiring too early or too late. So I try to strike a balance. Artvandeleghe did a nice job of finding the decent matches. It is no easy task.
As for the sleeve issues, I am not sure what to do. When you use the classic uniforms, many teams lose the stripes on long sleeves. Which I tend to think looks bad. Some teams get to keep the stripes though. Last year, the second roster I made, I did not use long sleeves at all for that reason. Thoughts on the sleeve issue? Are you ok with no stripes for certain teams for the guys with long sleeves? OR... should I use standard sleeves so the stripes are always present?
Again, as you play games with the roster so far, please let me know how things are going. If something is really messed up it is easier to fix at this stage. I am still working on playbooks for the teams and will eventually post a list on here. One thing I am noticing is that the Pass Balanced playbook causes the CPU to throw the ball way too much.
Anyway, keep me informed on your games. I am still working on the AFC EAST. I did not have as much roster time as I wanted this past weekend and so far I have been really busy with grading mountains of papers this week. So I have been a little behind where I want to be. But I will catch up!