Pro Football Focus to adjust player ratings

[guff]

Has anyone considered using PFF's "signature stats" to adjust ratings?

I was considering getting PFF elite which includes signature stats ($200/yr), it gives stats specific to a position, for instance it has a QB accuracy rating which gives credit to the QB for throwing a catchable pass even if the WR drops it.

I used to have the PFF subscription long ago and integrated their ratings into the madden rosters.

If anyone is interested in getting something together to try this please let me know.

[chunt04]

What system are you looking to do this for? If you look back through the roster forum here you will find my old thread proposing this idea last year. I would be interested, as I think it adds that extra level of realism to a roster and I love how PFF tracks all of these statistics. I'll get you the name of the thread.

Here's the link:
Madden 17 OS Community Rosters (Xbox)

[guff]

PS4, yeah I'll check that thread out. Thanks

[SStory1993]

I am putting a roster together using pff statistics as we speak. My focus is to bring madden ratings to a HOF type system similar to 2k where players rated at 99 are the best at their position. At least with the data I have available. My ratings are based on a 32 game progression favoring the most recent 16 games.
I am trying to incorporate the ideas the FBGrating used, but translate it where you can actually use the rosters in franchise mode. I am adjusting the speed, acceleration, agility, and vertical based on the best information I can retrieve and than using Signature stats to transform tackle, pass rush, run-stop, catching, etc.

This is a project I have worked on for many years, and I believe this year is the year to share it. Would love to have help implementing it.

Here are some overalls based on a HOF scale using PFF ratings.

Tom Brady NE 98
Aaron Donald LAR 98
Julio Jones ATL 96
Khalil Mack OAK 96
Luke Kuechly CAR 96
Rob Gronkowski NE 94
J.J. Watt HST 94
Matt Ryan ATL 93
Aaron Rodgers GB 93
Marshawn LynchOAK 93
Le'Veon Bell PIT 93
Mike Evans TB 93
Marshal Yanda BLT 93
Brandon GrahamPHI 93
Cameron Jordan NO 93
Von Miller DEN 93
Calais Campbell JAX 93
Eric Weddle BLT 93
Andrew Luck IND 92
Russell Wilson SEA 92
Antonio Brown PIT 92
A.J. Green CIN 92
Travis Frederick DAL 92
Kawann Short CAR 92
Chris Harris Jr. DEN 92
Greg Olsen CAR 91
Trent Williams WAS 91
Andrew WhitworthLAR91
Joe Thomas CLV 91
Zack Martin DAL 91
Ndamukong SuhMIA 91
Fletcher Cox PHI 91
Geno Atkins CIN 91
Jerrell Freeman CHI 91
Devin McCourty NE 91
Drew Brees NO 90
T.Y. Hilton IND 90
Doug Baldwin SEA 90
Larry Fitzgerald ARZ 90
Ryan Schraeder ATL 90
Tyron Smith DAL 90
Rodney Hudson OAK 90
Michael Bennett SEA 90
Justin Houston KC 90
Damon Harrison NYG 90
Leonard WilliamsNYJ 90
Mike Daniels GB 90
Bobby Wagner SEA 90
Sean Lee DAL 90
Dominique Rodgers-Cromartie NYG 90
Casey Hayward SD 90
Kam Chancellor SEA 90
Reshad Jones MIA 90
Eric Berry KC 90

Love to here feedback on what you think.

[SStory1993]

Quote: Originally Posted by chunt04

What system are you looking to do this for? If you look back through the roster forum here you will find my old thread proposing this idea last year. I would be interested, as I think it adds that extra level of realism to a roster and I love how PFF tracks all of these statistics. I'll get you the name of the thread. Here's the link: Madden 17 OS Community Rosters (Xbox)

After reading your link, that is everything I have been working on by myself.

A differences I noticed was though I loved the idea of a 100 point scale to rate players, I found it very difficult and a lot of work to maintain franchises with rerating rookies that it nearly took the fun out of game. My ratings are current based off of madden's 50-100 scale, so any user can continue to use the rosters throughout franchise modes without much issues. Once again I LOVE the idea of incorporating these ratings, and using PFF and Pro football outsiders as a source.

[YogiGarebear89]

Quote: Originally Posted by SStory1993

I am putting a roster together using pff statistics as we speak. My focus is to bring madden ratings to a HOF type system similar to 2k where players rated at 99 are the best at their position. At least with the data I have available. My ratings are based on a 32 game progression favoring the most recent 16 games. I am trying to incorporate the ideas the FBGrating used, but translate it where you can actually use the rosters in franchise mode. I am adjusting the speed, acceleration, agility, and vertical based on the best information I can retrieve and than using Signature stats to transform tackle, pass rush, run-stop, catching, etc. This is a project I have worked on for many years, and I believe this year is the year to share it. Would love to have help implementing it. Here are some overalls based on a HOF scale using PFF ratings. Tom BradyNE98 Aaron DonaldLAR98 Julio Jones ATL96 Khalil MackOAK96 Luke KuechlyCAR96 Rob GronkowskiNE94 J.J. Watt HST94 Matt Ryan ATL93 Aaron RodgersGB93 Marshawn LynchOAK93 Le'Veon BellPIT93 Mike EvansTB93 Marshal YandaBLT93 Brandon GrahamPHI93 Cameron JordanNO93 Von Miller DEN93 Calais CampbellJAX93 Eric WeddleBLT93 Andrew LuckIND92 Russell WilsonSEA92 Antonio BrownPIT92 A.J. Green CIN92 Travis FrederickDAL92 Kawann ShortCAR92 Chris Harris Jr.DEN92 Greg OlsenCAR91 Trent WilliamsWAS91 Andrew WhitworthLAR91 Joe ThomasCLV91 Zack MartinDAL91 Ndamukong SuhMIA91 Fletcher CoxPHI91 Geno AtkinsCIN91 Jerrell FreemanCHI91 Devin McCourtyNE91 Drew BreesNO90 T.Y. Hilton IND90 Doug BaldwinSEA90 Larry FitzgeraldARZ90 Ryan SchraederATL90 Tyron SmithDAL90 Rodney HudsonOAK90 Michael BennettSEA90 Justin HoustonKC90 Damon HarrisonNYG90 Leonard WilliamsNYJ90 Mike DanielsGB90 Bobby WagnerSEA90 Sean Lee DAL90 Dominique Rodgers-CromartieNYG90 Casey HaywardSD90 Kam ChancellorSEA90 Reshad JonesMIA90 Eric Berry KC90 Love to here feedback on what you think.

Where's OBJ fall in these ratings

The Apex Predators

[SStory1993]

Quote: Originally Posted by YogiGarebear89

Where's OBJ fall in these ratings The Apex Predators

He is an 89 to begin this season


History of his ratings based on my HOF scale is as follows at the end of each season:
2017:89
2016:90
2015:87
Rookie Rating: 77

Things I would like to point out:

- OBJ best season so far is his rookie year, but being that he only played 12 games, I am still taking his rookie rating into context which brings down his rating to 87. If I based my ratings solely on one season his rating would've been significantly higher, however the other side to that story is if everything is based on one season it will have major negative results on players that might have a down season such as JJ Watt's 2016 season. Where his rating based on that one year is a 67, which I feel doesn't nearly reflect the rating JJ Watt has earned/deserves.

[chunt04]

Quote: Originally Posted by SStory1993

He is an 89 to begin this season History of his ratings based on my HOF scale is as follows at the end of each season: 2017:89 2016:90 2015:87 Rookie Rating: 77 Things I would like to point out: - OBJ best season so far is his rookie year, but being that he only played 12 games, I am still taking his rookie rating into context which brings down his rating to 87. If I based my ratings solely on one season his rating would've been significantly higher, however the other side to that story is if everything is based on one season it will have major negative results on players that might have a down season such as JJ Watt's 2016 season. Where his rating based on that one year is a 67, which I feel doesn't nearly reflect the rating JJ Watt has earned/deserves.

What is your theory on rookies and younger players in the league? How do you handle the incoming rookies from drafting? I'd love to share ideas, as I may tinker with a roster once the 53 man roster comes out.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk