True height and weight or true girth?

[asantead22]

I am working on All-Time roster for Madden 19 for both PS4 and Xbox 1. I would like opinions on whether accuracy of weight and height is more important than true girth. The running back position is the hardest because of guys like Earl Campbell, Jerome Bettis, Ray Rice, etc... when you create Earl Campbell at his exact weight and height he looks too thin and you can’t match his real thigh size, however when you add extra weight he looks identical to real life counterpart! 99% of all players are 100% accurate weight/ height
IMG_2079.JPG Ray Rice exact weight and height Attachment 1 Ray Rice extra weight
Extra Weight on bottom


Sent from my iPhone using Operation Sports

[Godeep24]

Yes I agree need to add the girth so these studs stand out. Looking forward to these, have played your all time rosters in past years and always found them to be the best. thx


Sent from my iPad using Operation Sports

[Darth Aegis]

Add the girth. I do that to the current rosters. Otherwise everyone looks the same.

[asantead22]

Thanks fellas, the only positive EA added to the edits this year is the ability to edit over anyone which allows you to change the race, height, weight, etc...
I’m shooting for Thanksgiving but since Im doing both systems its tough. Thank god I stopped coaching football but my son is playing varsity football and we are in the playoffs! I think you guys will like the final product!!!


Sent from my iPhone using Operation Sports

[asantead22]

Example of how bad the guys at EA are at making rosters, look at Jason Pierre Paul. They have him with more belly bulge than he actually has. I am editing him now and will adjust his overall size to make him look like himself.


Sent from my iPhone using Operation Sports

[Darth Aegis]

Quote: Originally Posted by asantead22

Example of how bad the guys at EA are at making rosters, look at Jason Pierre Paul. They have him with more belly bulge than he actually has. I am editing him now and will adjust his overall size to make him look like himself. Sent from my iPhone using Operation Sports

It's unbelievable to me that the few body parts that they let us edit can only be used in the main menu only and not in CFM. That makes zero sense to me. Why not give us the choice to edit body parts in cfm? Smh... one of those so close by so far away moments. Epic fail.

[asantead22]

Quote: Originally Posted by Godeep24

Yes I agree need to add the girth so these studs stand out. Looking forward to these, have played your all time rosters in past years and always found them to be the best. thx Sent from my iPad using Operation Sports

Which system do you play?


Sent from my iPhone using Operation Sports

[Godeep24]

PS4


Sent from my iPad using Operation Sports