I've been testing and tweaking these for a few weeks now, and I think I've found a solid mix of settings to produce excellent stats and gameplay.
My areas of focus were:
-Fixing QB pass completion percentages
-Reducing big plays
-Making sure QBs weren't stationery in the pocket
-Making attributes matter
-Improving penalty frequency based on NFL averages
-Realistic game flow and outcomes
As the title says, these are ideal either for Coach Mode, or CPUvCPU (Play The Moments set to Slow in CFM). I tend to mix the two. So, here they are:
Front End
Game Options
EVen Teams: Off
Difficulty: All-Pro
Quarter Length: 15 Minutes
Play Clock: On
Accel. Clock: On
Min. Play Clock Time: 14 Seconds (10/20/16)
Game Speed: Normal (10/20/16)
Auto Flip: On
Coach Mode: On
Injuries: 50
Fatigue: 51 (10/20/16)
Player Speed Parity Scale: 75 (10/20/16)
Penalties
Offside: 25
False Start: 50 (11/22/16)
Offensive Holding: 45
Defensive Holding: 25
Facemask: 50
Illegal Block: 55
Roughing the Passer: 75
Defensive Pass Interference: 75
Offensive Pass Interference: Off - Improves WR/DB interactions
Kick Catch Interference: On
Intentional Grounding: On
Roughing the Kicker: On
Running Into the Kicker: On
Sliders
Same values for Player and CPU
QB Accuracy: 45 (11/6/16)
Pass Blocking: 60 (11/6/16) - Improves QB awareness in the pocket
WR Catching: 45 (11/6/16) - More errant throws, best WRs shine
Run Blocking: 60 (10/20/16) - Improves run game consistency
Fumbles: 45 (10/20/16) - Improves RB fumble likelehood
Reaction Time: 100 (10/24/16)
Interceptions: 35 (11/6/16)
Pass Coverage: 50 (11/6/16) - Fewer checkdowns, helps differentiate best DBs from average ones
Tackling: 55 (11/6/16)
FG Power: 65 (11/6/16)
FG Accuracy: 10 (10/20/16)
Punt Power: 45
Punt Accuracy: 55
Kickoff Power: 65 (10/20/16) - Better balance between toucbacks and returns
Visual Feedback (Optional)
Personal preference here, bu
On-Field Visual Feedback: Off
Drive Goals & XP Feedback: Off
Franchise Ticker: Scores Only
Franchise Gameplan Boost Notification: On
Coaching Tips: Off
Player Names: Pre-Snap Only
Auto Subs:
Out/In
All 60/80 except:
RB 83/85 (10/24/16)
Within CFM
Load sliders into CFM, then change the following:
Fatigue: 61 (10/20/16)
Penalties:
Offside: 65
False Start: 52 (11/22/16)
Offensive Holding: 70
Defensive Holding: 70
Facemask: 51
Illegal Block: 51
Roughing the Passer: 50
Defensive Pass Interference: 60
Auto Subs (same as front end, but don't forget to change them!):
All 80 in, 60 out except
RB (85 in, 83 out)
Player Progression Freq: Every 4 weeks (10/6/16)
XP Sliders:
http://www.operationsports.com/forum...p-sliders.html