These were on all pro settings and balancing out using coaching adjustments. For example when I set aggressive pass rush and had at 51 I got way too many penalties. I just made the jump from all pro to all madden which I'm seeing these do not translate over. I had to up almost everything on all madden. So, these penalties were for all pro not all madden. On all pro I was getting 10-12 a game though. I'm assuming your all madden player? I have always played all madden in the past but wanted to try all pro out as it's supposed to be more player ratings based and no cheats, etc. But I couldn't do it. The Cpu calls a completely different and smarter game on all madden. They use more of their playbook, defensively call more zone and zone blitzes and no cover 1 hardly at all. The thing that was the deal breaker on all pro for me though was even with 100 threshold, 100 man coverage and 100 reaction (yes this is not backwards after testing a ton) that streaks, outs, and double moves could not be guarded in man to man or even the double moves in zone blitzes. That was the deal breaker. I want to be able to call man to man defenses where on all madden I can with sliders tweaked. On all pro no matter what the CPU could not defend a few routes. I don't have to give myself rules and handcuff my play calling now. Anyways, I should update the OP with thresholds for both...