I can confirm player traits are broken in franchise

[Therebelyell626]

I did some testing after this was brought to my attention. The Bug is that in franchise the player traits are showing as on in the player card, but when you go to the edit player screen they are set to off (uses power/speed moves, possession catch, etc. etc.). Even if you turn them on and save, when you go back to the player edit screen they are set back to off.

I figured it may just be a visual glitch and that the player card was correct. So I did some testing. I ran the same basic 4-3 (4 man) rush in cover 2, cover 3, and cover 1, plus man five times each. I was usering the offense and sitting in the pocket waiting for the opposing team to sack my quarterback. I would then immediately go to the replay and examine each d-line man’s behavior. I can confirm that it appears that star players are NOT using advanced pass rush moves based on their traits.

This only seems to affect games in franchise mode as they seem to be working in play now and practice. Hopefully EA addresses this issue as it does effect gameplay in franchise

[New Jersey Giants]

Re: I can confirm player traits are broken in franchise

Smh yeah I noticed that too

[icicle22]

Re: I can confirm player traits are broken in franchise

So does this affect CPU and user controlled players? I use the Browns and seems like when I user control Myles Garret, he us underpowered as well. Or does this only affect if the CPU is controlling the player? I'm not sure I understand. Thanks.

[RyanLeaf16]

Re: I can confirm player traits are broken in franchise

So does this affect CPU and user controlled players? I use the Browns and seems like when I user control Myles Garret, he us underpowered as well. Or does this only affect if the CPU is controlling the player? I'm not sure I understand. Thanks.

It shouldn't impact user-controlled DL. The "uses swim/finesse move" feature in the traits is for AI controlled players. You have the ability to use these moves with the right stick if you're controlling the DL after the snap.

[icicle22]

Re: I can confirm player traits are broken in franchise

It shouldn't impact user-controlled DL. The "uses swim/finesse move" feature in the traits is for AI controlled players. You have the ability to use these moves with the right stick if you're controlling the DL after the snap.

OK. So we are just talking "traits" not "abilities" that are awarded to Superstars and Xfactors then? I was thinking of how when I am controlling Myles Garrett and I am rushing, it doesn't feel any different to me than if I pick other players on the line that are rated much lower. In years past, I could really feel the star players were different. This year feels less pronounced to me so I thought maybe this traits thing has something to do with it.

So....are we saying that no CPU controlled players will ever use swim moves or bull rush moves in franchise?

[roadman]

Re: I can confirm player traits are broken in franchise

I did some testing after this was brought to my attention. The Bug is that in franchise the player traits are showing as on in the player card, but when you go to the edit player screen they are set to off (uses power/speed moves, possession catch, etc. etc.). Even if you turn them on and save, when you go back to the player edit screen they are set back to off.

I figured it may just be a visual glitch and that the player card was correct. So I did some testing. I ran the same basic 4-3 (4 man) rush in cover 2, cover 3, and cover 1, plus man five times each. I was usering the offense and sitting in the pocket waiting for the opposing team to sack my quarterback. I would then immediately go to the replay and examine each d-line man’s behavior. I can confirm that it appears that star players are NOT using advanced pass rush moves based on their traits.

This only seems to affect games in franchise mode as they seem to be working in play now and practice. Hopefully EA addresses this issue as it does effect gameplay in franchise

So, is this for only when you edit player traits?

[forme95]

Re: I can confirm player traits are broken in franchise

Is this online or offline franchise? Is it default, active or downloaded rosters?

[RyanLeaf16]

Re: I can confirm player traits are broken in franchise

So....are we saying that no CPU controlled players will ever use swim moves or bull rush moves in franchise?

That is my understanding. Your AI controlled players & the opponents. I've been playing CFB25 only, so I haven't started a Madden 'chise to check, but I have been following this b/c I think it can really alter how a franchise plays out, XP awarded, etc.

[forme95]

Re: I can confirm player traits are broken in franchise

As asked earlier...... "Is this online or offline franchise? Is it default, active or downloaded rosters?"

Can you give more context.

I am playing an offline, default roster and all D lineman play as intended. Also, when this was first brought up, even before this thread, I was using offline, week 1 roster, and still saw plenty of animations to suggest this as not true. Dallas @ Cleveland, both Garrett and Parsons were bull rushing and pushing the tackle into the pocket. Also saw swim, shoulder dips, spins, and not just by them, both D-lines showed pressure and different animations.