Poll: Madden 05 (Original Xbox) or Madden 25 (Xbox One)

[Josam27o7]

I am interested to find out which you guys prefer. I prefer Madden 05 (original xbox).

[Josam27o7]

Poll results as of right now:

Madden 05 (Original Xbox): 77%

Madden 25 (Xbox One): 23%

It's amazing how an eight year old game is clearly preferred over the "next-gen" product. To this day I still have that Madden 05 soundtrack stuck in my head.

[Equinox831]

Quote: Originally Posted by Josam27o7

Poll results as of right now: Madden 05 (Original Xbox): 77% Madden 25 (Xbox One): 23% It's amazing how an eight year old game is clearly preferred over the "next-gen" product. To this day I still have that Madden 05 soundtrack stuck in my head.

Well what'd you expect? You picked an old fan favorite and put it up against a game that's been highly criticized and is not exactly in people's good graces. I'm surprised that Madden 25 even has 20%..

[bkrich83]

After playing Madden 25 on PS4, I'll say I prefer NextGen Madden 25 by a landslide. Although to be fair, I hated Madden 05, I was a 2k guy.

[TeeDogg]

05' was unplayable to me. its gameplay engine was really starting to show its age. M25 360 is starting to do the things I expected from 05' 06' and forward