There's not enough "free will" in Maddens... I've always felt that way about the series. If they wanna score, they're scorin'. Period. Not a defense in any playbook that'll stop 'em.
The "god mode" that the CPU gets into, where they are sure to score through hell or high water, is so recognizable to me by now, I can usually tell by midfield, with absolute certainty, that the CPU will march down the field and score.
I'm right 95% of the time when I spot the tell-tale signs that is happening, and I tell my GF, "CPU is in god mode again"... It's quite disappointing and discouraging on defense and makes you wonder, "why am I even trying, again?"...
I know what you mean all too well, man.. I know what you mean.