It's should be up to each individuals desire how they play their game.
It should be what you feel comfortable with.
ie, to each their own because it's too subjective and opinionated.
Completely agree.
My 2 cents - All Pro, even with ridiculously adjusted sliders, is too easy for me. I've always been an All Madden player, with both default and custom sliders dependent on how I thought Madden was playing that year.
All-Pro sometimes gives me tough games with the sliders I use. At least I feel more in control of what's going on. I think it plays better. Too easy to throw a pick in All-Madden. Maybe I'm not good enough.