Madden NFL 17 Team Ratings - NFC (Overall, Offense & Defense)

[jpdavis82]

Quote: Originally Posted by Mauer4MVP

Coach I 100% disagree. He's underachieved with Rodgers. Kicker - I would argue Walsh but I'm trying to be subjective. He had a better fg % last year and is 10th best all time. DB - No. Vikings have the best one in Smith and quite a bit of depth in Rhodes, Captain, Newman, Waynes, Blanton, Sendejo, Griffin, Alexander, Kearse (he's going to be a stud). I do think Packers probably have the 2nd and 3rd best DB's, but Vikings have more depth imo.

I'll take Shields over Rhodes and yes Smith is elite but I'll take our two Safeties combined over Vikings. We have a lot of young talent at CB, Randall is going to be a stud, Rollins isn't far behind.

BB and Brady went 10 years between SB victories, we will discuss this again in another five years and see how many more SB's GB has won by then. I like Zimmer but McCarthy has been around longer and GB has 7 straight years in the Playoffs, could have easily won it all 2 years ago and were a blown coverage by a rookie away from a real shot at going to the NFC championship last year.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[MoneyOvaHuds]

Quote: Originally Posted by Mauer4MVP

Please, tell me where I am wrong.

I like the Bears LBs more than Minny no homer but only Barr the LB I'll take over a Bears LB

[noplace]

Quote: Originally Posted by jsteele14

No respect for the Redskins. Worse than the Eagles?? How do they figure that? Sent from my SM-G920V using Tapatalk

I'm convinced ratings guy has a issue with the Skins. Outside of RB I'd put the Skins offense up against any team in the league talent wise. I'm ok with the defensive ratings until they prove otherwise. Thank god for edits because theres some serious shafting going on with alot of teams.

Another thing to note is that once cuts are made ratings will go up after releasing low grade players.

[jfsolo]

Kane has basically admitted on Twitter that team ratings are created from some voodoo mathematical formula that can't really be explained. When you play through many CFM seasons this is readily apparent.

[Gilley]

I usually don't care about ratings, but jeez, these are really strange.

[Mauer4MVP]

Quote: Originally Posted by kehlis

Can you two take this to PM so everyone else can discuss all the other teams please.

Sorry. I'll be done.

[Birdman18]

Quote: Originally Posted by jfsolo

Kane has basically admitted on Twitter that team ratings are created from some voodoo mathematical formula that can't really be explained. When you play through many CFM seasons this is readily apparent.

That shows you right there that they've built madden continuously on legacy code dating back probably to Madden 06 on 360. Which also is why I believe there's still so many legacy issues with the game that they haven't been able to fix.

[underdog13]

Quote: Originally Posted by Birdman18

That shows you right there that they've built madden continuously on legacy code dating back probably to Madden 06 on 360. Which also is why I believe there's still so many legacy issues with the game that they haven't been able to fix.

Heck I bet the ovr formula goes back to the ps2 days.

Sent from my XT1585 using Tapatalk