All Madden or All Pro

[charter04]

Quote: Originally Posted by kfish2013

Will sliders do anything? Or is that only when I'm playing as well?

Unless this year is different the sliders have no affect on the sim engine

[NateDogPack12]

In my humble opinion, you have to go All-Madden. All-pro QB AI is still very suspect and the CPU lacks the killer instinct to make you pay for mistakes. I have to crank up my user sliders in certain areas to accommodate for both the cheesy All-Madden competitiveness and the fact I'm probably not the best player, but I still like my experience compared to All-Pro.

[cable guy]

Quote: Originally Posted by jfsolo

I've been watching SimFB test All-Madden on YouTube, and listening to him say that it felt good, and seeing with my own eyes a decided lack of traditional All-Madden shenanigans, so I decided to played a game myself. Everyone who said that All-Madden is different now was on point. A few slider tweaks will be made, but not a whole lot, and when I start my CFM, it will be on this all new non cheating All-Madden level.

I have only played All Pro since I can remember. I recently just switched to All Madden, and I can tell u it played so unbelievably incredible, I can't believe it. AP played great, and I was having fun.... But the Cpu, basically doesn't try to win. For me anyway. I keep putting more house rules in, changing players traits, etc. Heck i had to put my r blk down to 5. did have to put the sliders into my favor, but I'm so happy I made the change. And I play on slow speed

Sent from my SM-G900V using Tapatalk

[cable guy]

Quote: Originally Posted by NateDogPack12

In my humble opinion, you have to go All-Madden. All-pro QB AI is still very suspect and the CPU lacks the killer instinct to make you pay for mistakes. I have to crank up my user sliders in certain areas to accommodate for both the cheesy All-Madden competitiveness and the fact I'm probably not the best player, but I still like my experience compared to All-Pro.

That nails it. The Cpu qb especially just lacks that killer instinct. On AP. Along with play calling. Also, I haven't personally seen this mentioned, the sliders on All Madden work like they should. They do exactly what u want them to do. I think my fellow All Pro players can understand what I'm saying. You touch 1 single itty bitty thing, and it changes other things. I may be wrong here. I'm only a couple games in.

Sent from my SM-G900V using Tapatalk