Madden 17 vs. 19

[drj32]

Is there any reason to upgrade from 17 to 19 if using standard HD TV?

I keep hearing about the tackling in 19 being more WWE style than it was in 17 which I've always hated, and that RPM looks worse than 17.

When I watch videos I cant tell the difference between 17 and 19 other than menus, etc.

What are the pros and cons?
thanks

[roadman]

Quote: Originally Posted by drj32

Is there any reason to upgrade from 17 to 19 if using standard HD TV? I keep hearing about the tackling in 19 being more WWE style than it was in 17 which I've always hated, and that RPM looks worse than 17. When I watch videos I cant tell the difference between 17 and 19 other than menus, etc. What are the pros and cons? thanks

Here's another thread to judge by:

https://forums.operationsports.com/f...7-18-19-a.html

Edit- Based on your last post from yesterday, it appears you already have 19 and play cpu vs cpu?

https://forums.operationsports.com/f...per-sim-7.html

[Rayzaa]

I have 17 as well. I biggest difference for me is the Sprint button function. 2017 doesn't have the One Cut which I think sucks. The fatique factor also isn't in 2017 which again, I think sucks in 2019.

The player motion I don't think there is a huge difference. The speed threshold which is in 2019 can be a factor if you like it. I do find games more competitive in 19 than in 17.
You just have to play 2019 and judge for yourself.

[underdog13]

Cpu QB A.I is 100% better in 19 and it isn't close imo.

Sent from my SM-G965U using Tapatalk

[TheDominator273]

One cut is amazing and worth the upgrade from 17 alone

[Jagsfan24]

Each madden game has it's pros and cons. Sure madden 19 sucks in many areas but overall i would prefer the newer animations and graphics and updated rosters. I still prefer the newer madden, there's always something better in it that the previous

[gr18]

Everybody has different opinions but I think '17 is the worst version of the last 4.'18 is a little better. I'm particularly fond of '16 gameplay but franchise is a little bare but '19 at this point is the best overall package this gen.

[booker21]

Quote: Originally Posted by underdog13

Cpu QB A.I is 100% better in 19 and it isn't close imo. Sent from my SM-G965U using Tapatalk

On the other hand Tackling is 100% worst on madden 2019 as they removed the physics completely and all tackles are scripted animations.