Madden NFL 21 Reveals 99 Club - 5 Players with an Overall 99 Rating, Agree or Disagree?

[Scott]

Quote: Originally Posted by Chiefsfan881129

Yes he has the strongest arm in the NFL by far a ton of NFL of legit experts have said his arm is stronger then Farve,Elway,Marino,Rodgers among others.. this is coming from actual player's exc, coaches scouts & more He has thrown the ball before & air distance was well over 70 yards! He threw a pass in warm-ups before a game vs Denver From back of 1 endzone to the other so his arm is legit.. As for the people saying he ran a 4.80 speed while true its game speed that matters & last year on multiple occasions he showed off his ability to scramble & he was way faster then an 81. Sent from my SM-G970U using Tapatalk

So edit it yourself then, some people care about accurate ratings. I believe 81 is fair for Mahomes.

[Archie56]

Quote: Originally Posted by Chiefsfan881129

Glad he is a 99 but still don't understand why he doesn't have 99 throw power i mean his arm is stronger then Josh Allen + Mahomes can chuck a ball 80+ yards with just a flick of the wrist & while 97 throw power is still awesome He should no doubt have 99 thp &, Allen 98 thp + Mahomes 81 speed is disrespectful he is faster then an 81 i would say he is more 85 to 86 speed but no more then that.. So I'm glad he's a 99 ovr as he should be for a very long time.. just wish they would make his other attributes realistic to his real life abilities... Sent from my SM-G970U using Tapatalk

So you're literally nitpicking about a 2 point difference? C'mon man! He's a 99 overall and you're complaining that his arm strength is a 97. That just seems a little silly

Sent from my SM-G975U using Tapatalk

[MajorSupreme]

Quote: Originally Posted by Archie56

So you're literally nitpicking about a 2 point difference? C'mon man! He's a 99 overall and you're complaining that his arm strength is a 97. That just seems a little silly Sent from my SM-G975U using Tapatalk

Even more silly is debating subjectively scored ratings that change frequently and are able to be edited by yourself.

[canes21]

I get why Madden rates the players the way they do. It's for marketing purposes and acts as a snapshot of the league for that particular year, but man, I'd absolutely love it if the ratings were looked at from an all-time perspective.

I'd like to see a 99 speed mean the fastest player in NFL history. 99 throw power means the strongest arm in NFL history and it should never be surpassed.

I know its not as marketable to have a game where your best player is rated 92 and the vast majority of players are 60s and 70s. It would be fun, to me, to go through a franchise, though, and know when I see a 95 rated player that I'm dealing with one of the best players in NFL history and need to watch for him. Instead, we have the ratings that are still too inflated for my taste and the game is oversaturated with good players to the point where they don't feel as special as I'd personally like to see.

[Scott]

I'd even prefer more of a ratings spread like OOTP.

[XtremeDunkz]

Man they are really dragging this out.

Sent from my SM-G960U using Tapatalk

[Steve_OS]

Quote: Originally Posted by MtVasuvius

other members of the 99 club were leaked as aaron donald, stephon gilmore, and christian mccaffrey all pretty well deserving imo

Official Madden twitter claims there are more.

https://twitter.com/EAMaddenNFL/stat...70164685856775

[canes21]

Theres going to be more than 4? Are the ratings going to just inflate back to where they used to be and then we can have another cycle of lowering them for Madden 26?