NCAA-10 Draft Class

[daniverson1973]

Quote: Originally Posted by TomBrady

Having all those 14 rookies rated higher than players like Gradkowski etc. is just wrong. There wont be 14 rookie QBs that will play that good. Josh Freeman started with a 71OVR. Do you really think that all those QBs are better than him?!

HUMMMMM..

okay, you are comparing my import rookie class to either your own ratings or i guess ea's default ratings????

either way, i have my own roster file i updated for many reasons

take a look at past posts in this forum and DL my roster and you'll see, and you'll prob like

[daniverson1973]

Quote: Originally Posted by Cowboys Fan 85

I think Tony Pike should be just a bit higher but everyone else is dead on accurate.

if you've worked on importing you know how it goes....

i agree Pike should be higher and bradford a point lower, but he is the best pro-style QB this year and wouldve been last year so 83 or higher is justifyable

off topic----the 'wildcard' is Tebow

[daniverson1973]

Quote: Originally Posted by dirtboyz

can you post your 2010 draft class. I just finished my first season and the classes i have are not that good.

on second thought, i just may do that man

update-soon

[daniverson1973]

Quote: Originally Posted by D-MAC©®

Not only that... Most of these guys are rated higher than Vince Young as well. Stafford was rated 79 on opening day rosters. Flacco is 85 on my current rosters(before IR glitch). The only problem I see is with some of these guys potential they'll be in the 90's in a season or 2. Yes these guys are great college QB's but they're not tested in the pros yet. IMO Tebow will be lucky to be in the 70's as a QB, Vick is 73 & I think Vick is miles ahead of him. Don't let all the hype blind you when creating these guys.

im numb to hype now

i am a ps2-er with madden man, so maybe i shouldve clarified

either way, my roster has most starting QB's 80 or higher, a few are below 80

[authentic]

Sorry man, but those ratings are far too high. The highest rated rookie to start the season might be 80. With Madden now lowering the rating system this year, more players in the 40s and 50s, some of those guys could be in the 50s and 60s.

[authentic]

Lower the ratings by 10 for each one. What's up with Tim Tebow being a 84 for TE or FB. You expect him to be a pro bowler in his first year playing a new position? haha

[D-MAC©®]

Exactly what I was trying to say.
Having "prospects" rated so high takes away the realism of the game.
Remember Madden is a simulated football game, not an "arcade" style game.
If you're after that sort of game try Blitz.

[daniverson1973]

i dont care for blitz, that is irrelevant

in my draft class, Tebow can be moved to TightEnd, which may very well happen in real life, so then he can play FB and/or TE
moving him to TE escalates his ratings, because he's obviously going to have very high breaktackle and strength ratings
if he stays at QB he'll have to develop before he hits the 80's

either way, i apprec your guys input, i'll post the file when i get the classes all done