Custom Madden NFL 11 Roster, Re-rating whole NFL ... Details inside! (Finished).

[at23steelers]

Quote: Originally Posted by Competitor

Well so far those are the ratings and the only reason I put JP so high was because he really does make a huge difference in every game but YOU can always switch Julius Peppers to a 94 and Haloti Ngata to a 95 if that makes more sense to you.

Yeah, that's a good idea!! Thanks.

[Competitor]

Quote: Originally Posted by at23steelers

Top 10: 1. Tom Brady 95 ovr 2. Julius Peppers 95 ovr 3. Peyton Manning 94 ovr 4. Arian Foster 94 ovr 5. Antonio Gates 94 ovr 6. Haloti Ngata 7. Kevin Williams 93 ovr 8. Andre Johnson 93 ovr 9. Jason Witten 93 ovr 10. Adrian Peterson 93 ovr Looks pretty good. Hats off for really stretching the ratings. Not trying to criticize since I know how long it takes and how much effort you put into it, but so far the only other player rated to high for me is Julius Peppers. Not on Tom Brady's level for how much impact he brings. But I know, I could always edit him, just wanted to give my opinion.

I see you changed and put in Ngata in there lol. You also took out CJ.





I have posted the MLB top ratings in just a second

[Competitor]

Finished the Middle Linebackers and now onto the Right Outside Linebackers! Only need to finish up the DBs after the ROLBs!!!!!

[at23steelers]

Quote: Originally Posted by Competitor

I see you changed and put in Ngata in there lol. You also took out CJ.

Yeah, I forgot about him. I glanced over DE's I guess, so adding him knocked off C. Johnson. This wasn't my top 10, just posted it so it was easier to compare the players.

[Competitor]

Quote: Originally Posted by at23steelers

Yeah, I forgot about him. I glanced over DE's I guess, so adding him knocked off C. Johnson. This wasn't my top 10, just posted it so it was easier to compare the players.

I see, also I have been playing MW2 all day so I am just starting on the ROLBs right now and will at least start on the CBs somewhat .... I have stuff to keep me up so I will have more time to finish up!

[biggerpapi]

Cant wait for these to come out..hopefully soon. I was just wondering if you are rerating players (more specifically 2nd-4th string) based on how the players actually play or just lowering ratings for a bigger difference in overalls? Plz dont take that as an insult or anything I am just wondering lol. I just dont want to see all the backups with low skill ratings just because they arent starters.

ex. say there is a 4th string WR that IRL runs routes very well. Are you going to base his route running rating on that or just lower it cuz hes a 4th string WR and he shouldnt have a route run rating as high as the 1st or 2nd string WR?

[Competitor]

Quote: Originally Posted by biggerpapi

Cant wait for these to come out..hopefully soon. I was just wondering if you are rerating players (more specifically 2nd-4th string) based on how the players actually play or just lowering ratings for a bigger difference in overalls? Plz dont take that as an insult or anything I am just wondering lol. I just dont want to see all the backups with low skill ratings just because they arent starters. ex. say there is a 4th string WR that IRL runs routes very well. Are you going to base his route running rating on that or just lower it cuz hes a 4th string WR and he shouldnt have a route run rating as high as the 1st or 2nd string WR?

here I know this may not be a good example here but let me give you the best CIT CAT AWR and THE WORST all that stuff

AWR - 97 - 12
CTH - 96 - 50
RTE - 99 - 12
CIT - 99 - 15
SPC - 99 - 15
RLS - 99 - 12


So you see that there is a huge diff between the top guys and the lower guys.

[at23steelers]

Quote: Originally Posted by Competitor

here I know this may not be a good example here but let me give you the best CIT CAT AWR and THE WORST all that stuff AWR - 97 - 12 CTH - 96 - 50 RTE - 99 - 12 CIT - 99 - 15 SPC - 99 - 15 RLS - 99 - 12 So you see that there is a huge diff between the top guys and the lower guys.

To clarify his question: For example, on the Steelers, would Ziggy Hood have 2nd string DE ratings, even though he could start on most 3-4 D teams?? Now, I am not saying one way or another about Ziggy, just an example to clarify if it matters more on their own skill and not their position on that teams depth chart.