I agree with you 100%. But even with its flaws, I enjoyed the 2K series more. There will never be a perfect game and now that we do not have a choice, I think much more is expected of EA. Since this is a business though, we will probably get the opposite.
If you really think about it though, what is next-gen? Next-gen TV and movies only equate to a better picture. It does not guarantee or promise a better story. So if next-gen is only about a better picture, then I guess Microsoft and Sony have just suckered us into paying $10 more per game.
As much as I bash Madden, I did enjoy the gameplay a bit more than usual in Madden 06. If I would stop comparing the game to others, maybe I could enjoy it more.