A new setup for reviewing games!

[Blitzburgh]

Here it is guys! These sites need to put up an "Initial Review" After a minimum of ten hours of playing time. Then after several hours of more in depth game time, they should write up a "follow up review."

It should be more broken down into various catagories and discuss each aspect of the following....

I. Offense
a. passing
b. running
c. line blocking
d. play calling
e. control

II. Defense
a. control
b. play calling
c. line blocking
d. coverage

III. Special Teams
a. kicking
b. returning
c. play calling

IV. Presentation
a. pregame
b. preplay and postplay
c. half time
d. post game
e. stats
f. weather
g. commentary
h. sidelines interaction
I. on field referee system
J. atmosphere that football possesses
K. penalty system
L. Injury system

V. Graphics
a. player models
b. crowds
c. stadiums
d. sidelines
e. play calling screens

If all of the websites where to discuss each of these topics now about Madden 08 how well do you think it would rate? I would give it a 6 out of 10 honestly but probably an 8 out of 10 initially.

[Trevytrev11]

Quote: Originally Posted by Blitzburgh

Here it is guys! These sites need to put up an "Initial Review" After a minimum of ten hours of playing time. Then after several hours of more in depth game time, they should write up a "follow up review."

10 hours may not even be enough time, but I do beleive that some type of initial review can be made within 3-5 days, even if it is nothing more than a short list of initial impressions. If they want to go back and retract what they said and do a full review while later that is completely different, than that is their perogative, but like I said in another semi-related post, is that if they want to be a serious sports gaming site, then it needs to be done seriously.