i kno how u feel, i always start off on all pro then as i progress, i'll go to all madden but this year, for some reason all maden aint all madden, so i tried the my skill option and BAM scoring problem solved! also on the defense side my stats began to represent my oppenent's lack of scoring. like i user my mlb in my chise and for the first time im ending my seasons with 100+ tackles mainly because im not scoring on every drive on offense and getting 3 and outs every drive od defense my myskill stays between 783 and 800 and im usualy in the top five for scoring at about 27.4 ppg give or take two points
try it out, it worked for me