Will You Sign Mike Vick?

[MrNFL_FanIQ]

Quote: Originally Posted by oChaos_Nine

His speed and throwing power were much deserved. And his accuracy wasn't that good in Madden anyway, it's just that in Madden that rating doesn't count for much. Agree?

True. Realistically, you shouldn't be able to run and throw or throw of your back foot on every pass and have a perfect spiral on target. That's what made Vick even more unstoppable, because it made a guy who hardly completes 50% become captain accuracy.

For this new game, you'd have to rate him lower I'd think, jail can't help progression. At the very least, his AWR and ACC should be HORRIBLE. (Like they should have been anyway.)

[bigsmallwood]

Quote: Originally Posted by MrNFL_FanIQ

True. Realistically, you shouldn't be able to run and throw or throw of your back foot on every pass and have a perfect spiral on target. That's what made Vick even more unstoppable, because it made a guy who hardly completes 50% become captain accuracy. For this new game, you'd have to rate him lower I'd think, jail can't help progression. At the very least, his AWR and ACC should be HORRIBLE. (Like they should have been anyway.)

Must we continue the haterade...Like it or not Vick IS a GOOD QB...name 10 QB's right now that are better whose name is not Tom Brady, McNabb, or Manning?

[Hoovie]

I'd sign him if I think he would help my team

Why?

B/C Madden is not real life. It's a game and should be treated as such.

Do you guys cut players who commit crimes during the season? Honestly? What about steriods? Do you take them out of your lineups for X amount of games?

Please...

[NuJoiseySoulja]

In real life, Panthers should sign Vick (even though you cant sign Vick, he is on trading block right now)

But Panthers should sign Vick so Jake Delhomme gets a boost. David Carr gave Jake a kick in the butt and he threw 8 touchdowns and 1 interception before getting hurt. He needs competiton. I am hoping Byron comes to Carolina! Besides the point.

In the video game, yeah I'd sign Vick too.

also, off topic - Ian, Kordell Stewart has been looking to make a come back this year, can you throw him in the Free Agent pool in 10? :OD

[datboitex8]

Quote: Originally Posted by Hoovie

I'd sign him if I think he would help my team Why? B/C Madden is not real life. It's a game and should be treated as such. Do you guys cut players who commit crimes during the season? Honestly? What about steriods? Do you take them out of your lineups for X amount of games? Please...

great post LOL

[LingeringRegime]

Quote: Originally Posted by Jetpac

The hypocracy of our fickle country. Shoot a deer its a sport. Kill a Dog your the most hated human being on earth. YES I would sign Vick in a heartbeat.

Electrocuting and torturing dogs is a lot worse than hunting deer.

[bigsmallwood]

Quote: Originally Posted by DEFTFUNDAMENTALZ

Electrocuting and torturing dogs is a lot worse than hunting deer.

As a dog lover I agree. BUT people do deserve second chances. That is only fair my friend.

[MrNFL_FanIQ]

Quote: Originally Posted by bigsmallwood

Must we continue the haterade...Like it or not Vick IS a GOOD QB...name 10 QB's right now that are better whose name is not Tom Brady, McNabb, or Manning?

Palmer, Roethlisberger, Garrard, Schaub, Collins, Flacco, Edwards, Pennington, Rivers, Cutler, Rodgers, Garcia, Brees, Ryan, Eli, Romo, Campbell, Warner.

And that's assuming Vick would return at the top of his game, no doubt his skills would have degraded thanks to jail.

Vick can run, he has a strong arm. He's a terrible decision maker and has mediocre at best accuracy. He never was a good quarterback to begin with, he just a mediocre QB who could make a flashy run play from time to time.