New QB Ratings. Who gets what?

[Glorious Arc]

where do you draw the line and say hey this guy is or is not an elite player. I suck with numbers and matching but i still ahve a decent eye to go REALLY thats wrong.

I see people giving Jason Campbell 90s lmao thats great it really is. hes average as it stands right now.

Aaron Rogers is decent as well but hes no peyton.

kmart had a good couple of players set but i think they sohuld have been a little higher with manning's and brady's stats. as well Ben should have a higher like 90ish throw on the run because honestly when hes outside the pocket and running around hes a better QB then when hes standing still.

[NBA2k8 CHAMP]

Peyton Manning

Deep Ball Acc: 84

Medium Acc: 88

Short Acc: 92

Throw On Run: 48

Play Action: 96

[NBA2k8 CHAMP]

Just to get a comparison from a elite to a bad QB

Vince Young

Deep Ball Acc 69

Medium Acc 73

Short Acc 78

Throw On Run 40

Play Action 68

[frankrizzo380]

Quote: Originally Posted by NBA2k8 CHAMP

Just to get a comparison from a elite to a bad QB Vince Young Deep Ball Acc 69 Medium Acc 73 Short Acc 78 Throw On Run 40 Play Action 68

u forgot his suicide rating...that was soooooo wrong of me

[marktg30]

Quote: Originally Posted by frankrizzo380

u forgot his suicide rating...that was soooooo wrong of me

ROFL Sauce!!!

[NYyankz225]

Quote: Originally Posted by tmulk

Jason Campbell Deep Acc. 95 medium acc 97 short acc 99 on the run 92 PA 98 Colt Brennan Deep Acc. 99 medium acc 99 short acc 102 the run 99 PA 99

Must be a joke.


Aaron Rodgers:

1. Deep Ball Accuracy: 84
2. Medium Passing Accuracy: 87 (this is where he shines imo)
3. Short Passing Accuracy: 83
4. Throw on the Run: 92 (if he gets underrated here I'll cry)
5. Play Action: 83

[kcarr]

Quote: Originally Posted by frankrizzo380

4. Throw on the Run: he and most other pocket passers sould recieve a 25 point hit on the run with respect to the type of pass he is tryna throw (short,med,deep), just a thought

I am going to partially disagree here. While they should take a hit while on the run and for pocket QBs it should be a pretty heavy hit there should be more going into it than just an across the board 25 point hit.

There needs to be a formula based on each type of on the run throw as far as direction of movement and direction of throw which takes into account the throw on the run rating and the speed of movement as compared to the player's maximum speed and will give back a percentage value that should be taken off of the player's normal accuracy for that type of throw. Also, shorter throws should maybe take less of an accuracy hit on the run than deeper throws.

As for drew's deep accuracy yes it should be high. Should be the highest in the game and probably around 95 or so with the next highest being around 90. His throw power however should probably be high 60s to low 70s.

[frankrizzo380]

yeah ure right 25 points may be a bit drastic because theyre all pros but i just thought it should be a point hit and not a rating like a 12 or 17 point hit imo