while this is amusing i have worse story to tell...
mine was in actually gameplay:
So im playing with vikings in franchise mode, all-madden, against the saints. I expect to get beat on pass defense thanks to the combination of robo qb and drew brees but i manage to injure brees in the first quarter (injury report says he's out for 3 quarters, so he'll be back in the final quarter)... so his backup comes in (i don't remember his name) and i manage to sack him and injure him within 2 plays of his arrival... the injury report says he's out for the game!!!! so i go to their depth chart to see how bad the 3rd string qb is.... THEY DON'T HAVE ONE!!!!
... so i go to the next play and then go to replay to see who's throwing the ball.. it's wetherford (k or p.. not sure) and i can't remember what his passer ratings were but i think they were like 20 + 20ish.. anyway for 3 quarters he proceeded to throw 22/26 3tds 0 int 2 sacks... most of the passes were woblers and sometimes really weak but he still won the game for them... brees came back in and killed me off... i was so angry but couldn't help but laugh... ahhh good times