Official post your own Rosters and ratings

[AlexBrady]

Quote: Originally Posted by marktg30

Browns - QB Brady Quinn - 79 Derek Anderson - 79 HB Jamal Lewis - 85 Jerome Harrison - 77 Noah Herron - 74 FB Lawerence Vickers - 88 WR Braylon Edwards - 88 Donte Stallworth - 84 TE Robert Royal - 78 Steve Heiden - 76 OL Joe Thomas - 98 Eric Steinbach - 90 Hank Fraley - 84 Rex Hadnot - 84 Issac Sowells - 78 DL Corey Williams - 85 Shaun Rogers - 97 Shaun Smith - 80 LB Kamerion Wimbley - 84 D'Qwell Jackson - 85 Leon Williams - 84 Aaron Curry - 86 (I wish) CB Eric Wright - 83 Brandon McDonald - 83 S Brodney Pool - 84 Mike Adams - 82 P Dave Zastudil - 87 K Phil Dawson - 86 (Please up his power to a 56-57 yard length) KR/PR Josh Cribbs - 99 (Add something for 'Branching Tackles')

REVISED

QB
Brady Quinn - 68
Derek Anderson - 69

HB
Jamal Lewis - 78
Jerome Harrison - 69
Noah Herron - 65

FB
Lawerence Vickers - 73

WR
Braylon Edwards - 78
Donte Stallworth - 71

TE
Robert Royal - 68
Steve Heiden - 66

OL
Joe Thomas - 84
Eric Steinbach - 80
Hank Fraley - 73
Rex Hadnot - 70
Issac Sowells - 68

DL
Corey Williams - 72
Shaun Rogers - 85
Shaun Smith - 69

LB
Kamerion Wimbley - 78
D'Qwell Jackson - 75


CB
Eric Wright - 72
Brandon McDonald - 72

S
Brodney Pool - 72
Mike Adams - 68

P
Dave Zastudil - 74

K
Phil Dawson - 79

KR/PR
Josh Cribbs - 83

[AlexBrady]

Quote: Originally Posted by salbowski

Vikings: T Jackson - 75 Rosenfels - 79 Peterson - 97 C Taylor - 86 Berrian - 88 Rice - 75 Harvin - 80 Shiancoe - 84 Kleinsasser - 76 (high block/low rec) mckinnie - 90 hutch - 97 sullivan - 81 Herrera - 76 cook - 75 jared allen - 97 k williams - 96 p williams - 94 edwards - 81 leber - 79 e.j henderson - 93 greenway - 89 winfield - 90 griffin - 80 m williams - 87 t johnson - 80 longwell - 90 kluwe - 80 childress - 4 OFFENSE: 83 (average of starters) DEFENSE: 88 OVERALL: 86

REVISED

Vikings:

T Jackson - 67
Rosenfels - 65

Peterson - 90
C Taylor - 77

Berrian - 74
Rice - 68


Shiancoe - 72
Kleinsasser - 69

mckinnie - 76
hutch - 82
sullivan - 71
Herrera - 66
cook - 64

jared allen - 84
k williams - 83
p williams - 80
edwards - 74

leber - 69
e.j henderson - 77
greenway - 73

winfield - 78
griffin - 66

m williams - 72
t johnson - 70

longwell - 79
kluwe - 74

[83evans]

Quote: Originally Posted by AlexBrady

REVISED Tom Brady: 95 Fred Taylor: 72 Laurence Maroney: 66 Kevin Faulk: 69 (3rd Down Back: 83) Randy Moss: 91 Wes Welker: 83 Joey Galloway: 67 Greg Lewis: 55 Ben Watson: 71 Chris Baker: 63 Matt Light: 76 Logan Mankins: 76 Dan Koppen: 76 Stephen Neal: 69 Nick Kaczur: 65 Richard Seymour: 81 Vince Wilfork: 85 Ty Warren: 79 Adalius Thomas: 79 Jerod Mayo: 76 Tedy Bruschi: 65 Rosevelt Colvin: 63 Ellis Hobbs: 69 Leigh Bodden: 70 Shawn Springs: 68 Jonathan Wilhite: 64 Brandon Meriweather: 70 James Sanders: 69 Rodney Harrison: 71 Stephen Gostkowski: 79 Chris Hanson: 72 SCALE 100-90 Elite Player 89-80 Outstanding Player 79-75 Solid Starter 74-70 Good Starter 69-65 Adequate Starter 64-60 Good Backup 59-55 Adequate Backup 54-50 Marginal Backup 49-45 Below Average Backup Player/Core Special Teams Player 20 Developmental Player

If this is your scale then the bills go like this


Trent- 70
Lynch- 89
TO- 90
Evans- 88
Reed- 65
Parrish- 61
Hardy- 62
Johnson- 62
Peters- 92
Walker- 78
Butler- 77
Schobel- 79
Kelsay- 65
Stroud- 86
Ellis- 60
Pos- 77
Mitchell- 75
McKelvin- 76
McGee- 78
Whitner- 89
Lindell- 85
Moorman- 95

[ryby6969]

Quote: Originally Posted by da ThRONe

The same thing could have been said about Eli Manning in the New York media area and there still wasnt the same kinda backlash! I guess there's no use in trying to point it out I guess the eyes see what they wanna see!

You are wrong about Eli Manning with this comment. The only reason why Eli is still in New York is for the simple fact that he got hot in the playoffs and made it to the super bowl and won it. They were calling for his and Coughlin's head before they made the run in the playoffs and both would have more than likely been gone had they not accomplished what they did.

And as far as Vick, ask yourself this. Who do you think Roddy White would rather have there now? Vick or Ryan? Would Vick have been able to do the same thing with possibly a less talented team than he had ever had?

[CreatineKasey]

Brady I hope your attitude towards rating gets emulated in Madden 10. It'd help separate that rare player playing at legendary status and make us appreciate players with 90's. I never understood why the full rating scale isn't used.

What's wrong with rating an average player 50 a lower level player 25, above average 75 and legendary in the 90's?

[83evans]

I wonder how this works on 09. Im going to try it.

[AlexBrady]

Quote: Originally Posted by 83evans

If this is your scale then the bills go like this Trent- 70 ON THE MONEY for the most part Lynch- 89 LOWER TO- 90 LOWER Evans- 88 LOWER Reed- 65 ON THE MONEY Parrish- 61 ON THE MONEY Hardy- 62 ON THE MONEY Johnson- 62 ON THE MONEY Peters- 92 GREAT PLAYER BUT LOWER Walker- 78 LOWER Butler- 77 LOWER Schobel- 79 LOWER (though he is a bit underrated by the media) Kelsay- 65 ON THE MONEY Ellis- 60 ON THE MONEY Pos- 77 A BIT LOWER Mitchell- 75 LOWER McKelvin- 76 LOWER McGee- 78 LOWER Whitner- 89 TOP PLAYER ON THE TEAM, A TAD LOWER Lindell- 85 LOWER Moorman- 95 LOWER (HE IS VERY GOOD THOUGH)

Decent

[AlexBrady]

Quote: Originally Posted by 83evans

I wonder how this works on 09. Im going to try it.

It won't work out Mr. Evans.

Quote: Originally Posted by CreatineKasey

Brady I hope your attitude towards rating gets emulated in Madden 10. It'd help separate that rare player playing at legendary status and make us appreciate players with 90's. I never understood why the full rating scale isn't used. What's wrong with rating an average player 50 a lower level player 25, above average 75 and legendary in the 90's?

I take these ratings very seriously (probably too seriously) and I wont just hand out 80s or 90s for the heck of it. Those areas are reserved for the upper echelon players. Currently, the league is filled with alot of average/nice players and about 12-15 great players. Unfortunately, many fans tend to overrate their own players and label them as great when they are just nice/average.

There is absolutely nothing wrong with evaluating a player and coming to the conclusion that he comes out as a 45. He is what he is. There are rare players in the league and they are employed by the teams that are good year in and year out.(Colts, Pats, Steelers)