Official post your own Rosters and ratings

[83evans]

Quote: Originally Posted by AlexBrady

Decent

Lynch- 86
Evans- 85
Owens- 86
Peters- 89
Walker- 75
Butler- 73
Schobel- 77
Pos- 75
Mitchell-73
McGee- 76
McKelvin- 74
Whitner- 87
Lindell- 79
Moorman- 90

[AlexBrady]

Quote: Originally Posted by 83evans

Lynch- 86 Evans- 85 Owens- 86 Peters- 89 Walker- 75 Butler- 73 Schobel- 77 Pos- 75 Mitchell-73 McGee- 76 McKelvin- 74 Whitner- 87 Lindell- 79 Moorman- 90

There you go.

[Americas Team1]

Dallas Cowboys

QB-T.Romo-92

RB-M.Barber-88

RB-F.Jones-80

RB-T.Choice-76

TE-J.Witten-98

TE.M.Bennett-79

WR-R.Williams-89

WR-P.Crayton-82

WR-M.Austin-74

OT-F.Adams-88

OT-M.Colombo-86

OG-K.Koiser-80

OG-L.Davis-93

C-A.Gurode-91

DE-I.Olshansky-82

DE.M.Spears-77

DT-J.Ratliff-90

OLB-D.Ware-98

OLB-A.Spencer-77

MLB-B.James-87

MLB-K.Brooking-80

CB-T.Newman-95

CB-M.Jenkins-79

FS-K.Hamlin-85

SS-G.Sensabaugh-80

K-N.Folk-93

P-M.McBriar-97

[g2thecore]

Quote: Originally Posted by CreatineKasey

Brady I hope your attitude towards rating gets emulated in Madden 10. It'd help separate that rare player playing at legendary status and make us appreciate players with 90's. I never understood why the full rating scale isn't used. What's wrong with rating an average player 50 a lower level player 25, above average 75 and legendary in the 90's?

What's wrong is that EA would have to deal with hundreds of whining average NFL players (who also happen to play Madden) who will be pissed when they find out they're a 70 in Madden.

Though I share your vision, I can understand the backlash that comes with even attempting something like this. These players whine about their speed rating as it is all the time, imagine what would happen if their overall ratings were to drop in the mid 70's. Blasphemy!

[83evans]

Quote: Originally Posted by g2thecore

What's wrong is that EA would have to deal with hundreds of whining average NFL players (who also happen to play Madden) who will be pissed when they find out they're a 70 in Madden. Though I share your vision, I can understand the backlash that comes with even attempting something like this. These players whine about their speed rating as it is all the time, imagine what would happen if their overall ratings were to drop in the mid 70's. Blasphemy!

Or the players in the 20

[Hotlanta]

Quote: Originally Posted by AlexBrady

SCALE 100-90 Elite Player 89-80 Outstanding Player 79-75 Solid Starter 74-70 Good Starter 69-65 Adequate Starter 64-60 Good Backup 59-55 Adequate Backup 54-50 Marginal Backup 49-45 Below Average Backup Player/Core Special Teams Player 20 Developmental Player

Hmm..Taking a shot for Atlanta (Who we have for now) I would say.

QB:
M. Ryan (78)

RB:
M. Turner (85)
J. Norwood (77)

FB:
O. Mughelli (74)

WR:
R. White (79)
M. Jenkins (73)
H. Douglas (70)

TE:
J. Peelle (63)

OL: (Did pretty well this season but still have to guess here...)
S. Baker (76)
J. Blalock (73)
T. McClure (76)
H. Dahl (71)
T. Clabo (74)

DL:
J. Abraham (88)
J. Anderson (72)
J. Babineaux (73)

LB:
C. Lofton (73)
M. Peterson (76)

DB:
C. Houston (74)
C. Jackson (68)
B. Grimes (69)
Still Missing Strong Safety....
E. Coleman (75)

K/P:
J. Elam (76)
M. Koenen (80)

[Donny_Moore]

Quote: Originally Posted by Hotlanta

Hmm..Taking a shot for Atlanta (Who we have for now) I would say. QB: M. Ryan (78) RB: M. Turner (85) J. Norwood (77) FB: O. Mughelli (74) WR: R. White (79) M. Jenkins (73) H. Douglas (70) TE: J. Peelle (63) OL: (Did pretty well this season but still have to guess here...) S. Baker (76) J. Blalock (73) T. McClure (76) H. Dahl (71) T. Clabo (74) DL: J. Abraham (88) J. Anderson (72) J. Babineaux (73) LB: C. Lofton (73) M. Peterson (76) DB: C. Houston (74) C. Jackson (68) B. Grimes (69) Still Missing Strong Safety.... E. Coleman (75) K/P: J. Elam (76) M. Koenen (80)

Harsh! And you are a Falcons fan!?!!? You guys are tough!

Roddy White only a solid player? He is a stud. He did it with crap QBs one year (Harrington/Redman). And Matt Ryan the next. He is legit.

[Hotlanta]

Quote: Originally Posted by Donny_Moore

Harsh! And you are a Falcons fan!?!!? You guys are tough! Roddy White only a solid player? He is a stud. He did it with crap QBs one year (Harrington/Redman). And Matt Ryan the next. He is legit.

Yes! Now I know for a fact he's an 80+ player. I win lol
I was thinking low 80's but I still don't know high's and low's for each position or better yet starters.

If this is harsh I guess this is low for them and maybe where getting more love then I showed? Throw me a bone man I wanna now lol