Official player ratings

[83evans]

I made this before but it involved people to post a whole team, this is just for certain players. Post what you think certain players should be rated using this chart.


90-100- Elite- Manning, Brady
85-89- Outstanding- AP, LT
80-85- Great- Ben, Lynch
70-79- Good starter
60-69- Good backup
50-59- Good STer
30-49- Bad players


Ill start off

Manning- 97
Brady- 96
LT- 86
Lynch- 85

[PGaither84]

I just would like to add that while this list was good in the past, Ian said there is a whole new ratting philosophy and that there will be greater differences between players new rattings. our old style of judging what an 87 ment is gone. A player in 09 who is an 82 may only be a 76 in 10. Not because they got worse.

[DeLuX]

LT - 98

Brady - 98

Rivers - 95

P.Manning - 98

Eli Manning - 76

Cutler - 70

Big Ben - 85

AD - 92

Gates - 97

Merriman - 96

[canes21]

^^^ Bias much?

[Brandon_c993]

Quote: Originally Posted by canes21

^^^ Bias much?

lol I second this

[Brandon_c993]

Manning-97
Brady-97
Fitz-95
AP-94
Michael Turner-93
Roethlisberger-92
Rivers-91
Andre Johnson-91
Calvin Johnson-91
LT-89
Lynch-87
MJD-87

[illwill10]

Andre Johnson should be rated nearly the same as Fitz. If Andre's team would've made the playoffs he would've had nearly the same stats as Fitz.
Plus Brady should be rated a point under Manning. He might not be able to have a elite season recoverin fully with his injury, and might start slow.

[tyler289]

Quote: Originally Posted by DeLuX

LT - 98 Brady - 98 Rivers - 95 P.Manning - 98 Eli Manning - 76 Cutler - 70 Big Ben - 85 AD - 92 Gates - 97 Merriman - 96

First, LOL



For some of my thoughts:

Manning 96
Brady 96
AD 97
Big Ben 89
Fitz 92