Madden Player Ratings (09)

[seriousluboy83]

Quote: Originally Posted by xtremedunkz

sounds good Donny, but personally I'd like to see that even significantly lower. Maybe to an average of one per team or less. 95+ imo should be Pro Bowl every season first ballot HoF worthy.

Naw bro I think those are good numbers....there are 32 teams wit 54 players (if it's still tha same roster numbers from 09) that means there are 1000+ players in the madden not including FA's and for only 50 to be in the 95+ rating category is great

[RufusTruthfist]

Quote: Originally Posted by xtremedunkz

sounds good Donny, but personally I'd like to see that even significantly lower. Maybe to an average of one per team or less. 95+ imo should be Pro Bowl every season first ballot HoF worthy.

You really think no more than 32 players in the league are 95+ players? Just about every team in the league has a 95+ player and a lot of teams have multiples. 50-ish sounds about right to me.

[Americas Team1]

Quote: Originally Posted by xtremedunkz

99 players..hmm, Ed Reed, Fitz, Asomugha

Maybe D.Ware or Witten

[salbowski]

Let's try to get the 50 then.

QBs:

Manning 99
Brees- 97
Brady- 97

Hb:
Peterson- 97
Lt- 95
Westbrook- 95

FB- :
none

Wr:
Fitz- 98
A johnson- 97
Moss - 96

Te:
Gate- 95
Witten- 96
Gonzalez- 95

T:
Peters-96 (from donny's twitter, he seems to rate him... im not as convinced after last season but i don't do the ratings)
J Thomas - 95
Diehl- 95

G:
Hutchinson- 97
Davis- 96
Snee- 97

C:
Ohara- 95
Mangold- 95

De:
Mathis- 95
J allen- 97
Mario Williams- 97
Peppers- 96
Abraham- 95
Tuck- 95


DT:
Haynesworth- 99
K williams- 97
Harris- 95

Olb:
Ware- 98
Harrison- 98
Merriman- 96
Bulluck- 95
A Thomas- 95

Mlb:
Willis- 97
Ray Lewis- 95
Beason- 95
Urlacher- 95

CB:
Bailey- 97
Asomugha- 99
Mathis- 95
Samuel- 95
Al Harris- 95

FS:
Ed Reed- 99

SS:
Polamalu- 98
Sanders- 96
A Wilson- 95

K:
Bironas- 95

P:
Lechler- 96
Lee- 95

50 Players... Im sure im missing some.

[seriousluboy83]

Quote: Originally Posted by salbowski

Let's try to get the 50 then. QBs: Manning 99 Brees- 97 Brady- 97 Hb: Peterson- 97 Lt- 95 Westbrook- 95 FB- : none Wr: Fitz- 98 A johnson- 97 Moss - 96 Te: Gate- 95 Witten- 96 Gonzalez- 95 T: Peters-96 (from donny's twitter, he seems to rate him... im not as convinced after last season but i don't do the ratings) J Thomas - 95 Diehl- 95 G: Hutchinson- 97 Davis- 96 Snee- 97 C: Ohara- 95 Mangold- 95 De: Mathis- 95 J allen- 97 Mario Williams- 97 Peppers- 96 Abraham- 95 Tuck- 95 DT: Haynesworth- 99 K williams- 97 Harris- 95 Olb: Ware- 98 Harrison- 98 Merriman- 96 Bulluck- 95 A Thomas- 95 Mlb: Willis- 97 Ray Lewis- 95 Beason- 95 Urlacher- 95 CB: Bailey- 97 Asomugha- 99 Mathis- 95 Samuel- 95 Al Harris- 95 FS: Ed Reed- 99 SS: Polamalu- 98 Sanders- 96 A Wilson- 95 K: Bironas- 95 P: Lechler- 96 Lee- 95 50 Players... Im sure im missing some.

pretty good list dude

[gr18]

I'd add Freeney,Wayne,Charles Woodson and Steve Smith but Al Harris is a no and Mathis probably not.

[NFLHITMAN]

1. Peyton Manning
2. Tom Brady
3. Randy Moss
4. Andre Johnson
5. Ed Reed
6. Troy Polamalu
7. James Harrison
8. Albert Haynesworth
9. Asomugha
10. Larry Fitzgerald
11. DeMarcus Ware
12. Adrian Peterson
13. Steve Hutchinson
14. Joey Porter
15. Patrick Willis
16. Drew Brees
17. Walter Jones
18. Adrian Wilson
19. Joe Thomas
20. Jason Peters
21. Mario Williams
22. Jason Whitten
23. Kevin Williams
24. Pat Williams
25. Tommie Harris
26. Kurt Warner
27. Anquan Boldin

That is the only people I think deserve a 90+ rating. These are the cream of the crop players right now IMO.

[dougdeuce]

Quote: Originally Posted by salbowski

Let's try to get the 50 then. Lt- 95

hate to say it Charger fans, but he just isn't that good anymore... no way he's a 95 this year