Madden Player Ratings (09)

[seriousluboy83]

Quote: Originally Posted by NFLHITMAN

Peyton Manning Tom Brady Randy Moss Andre Johnson Ed Reed Troy Polamalu James Harrison Albert Haynesworth Asomugha Larry Fitzgerald DeMarcus Ware Adrian Peterson Steve Hutchinson Walter Jones Joe Thomas Jason Peters Mario Williams These are the only people I see possibly getting 95+

well it is....what it is (in your eyes)....donny said at most 50 wasnt completely accurate tho....perk that list up brah....17 is way too slim

[Brandon_c993]

Quote: Originally Posted by seriousluboy83

neither of these players make the cut of 95+ except 2 maybe....Wayne and Smith tha rest are on a decline 95+ only brah

lol did you just say Freeney was on the decline???

He had 1 bad season in 06 with 5.5 sacks 07 he was out for 7 games and 08 he was back up into the 10+ sack season....

you can't just look at 06 and 07 and say he is on the decline if anything he is getting back to that 16 sack season...

He was 7th out of all DE's and 11th overall in sacks...

He was also tied for 9th overall in forced fumbles...

Hardly on the decline....

[seriousluboy83]

Quote: Originally Posted by Brandon_c993

lol did you just say Freeney was on the decline??? He had 1 bad season in 06 with 5.5 sacks 07 he was out for 7 games and 08 he was back up into the 10+ sack season.... you can't just look at 06 and 07 and say he is on the decline if anything he is getting back to that 16 sack season... He was 7th out of all DE's and 11th overall in sacks... He was also tied for 9th overall in forced fumbles... Hardly on the decline....

ok put it like this 2 bad yrs....1 good yr....he's bout to be 30 and last yr he was rated 96....he down to 93 - 90 range easy

[carnalnirvana]

i dont think anyone should be 90+ because no one can do everything best from their position.

P. Manning is good but a 95 says he is god, he is my favorite player but with out the pieces he has in place on the colts he would be very 80-85 so i think we should chill with this stuff.

95 says he can do everything from the Qb position possible but realistically he cant.

he is not as fast as vick or young. he is not as witty or( careless) as farve. he is not as creative as Big Ben.

my point is yes he is accurate and very good but a 95 is too much, players do what they do because of the identity of their team not godly abilities that a madden 95 represent.

[seriousluboy83]

Quote: Originally Posted by carnalnirvava

i dont think anyone should be 90+ because no one can do everything best from their position. P. Manning is good but a 95 says he is god, he is my favorite player but with out the pieces he has in place on the colts he would be very 80-85 so i think we should chill with this stuff. 95 says he can do everything from the Qb position possible but realistically he cant. he is not as fast as vick or young. he is not as witty or( careless) as farve. he is not as creative as Big Ben. my point is yes he is accurate and very good but a 95 is too much, players do what they do because of the identity of their team not godly abilities that a madden 95 represent.

imma just pretend you didnt say peyton doesnt deserve a 95+

[carnalnirvana]

and i am going to pretend he didnt throw 6 picks more than once.

my second fav player behing Moss but none of then deserve that rating....

this game does not have the reasoning calculations to produce anything close to realistic with ratings like the ones i see people giving out.

A.D
95-stiff arm
95- elusiveness
95-juke
95-spin
are you serious does this even sound realistic. this type of garbage ratings is what causes his to throw off linemen that weigh twice his weight.

[SwayGod53]

Quote: Originally Posted by carnalnirvava

i dont think anyone should be 90+ because no one can do everything best from their position. P. Manning is good but a 95 says he is god, he is my favorite player but with out the pieces he has in place on the colts he would be very 80-85 so i think we should chill with this stuff. 95 says he can do everything from the Qb position possible but realistically he cant. he is not as fast as vick or young. he is not as witty or( careless) as farve. he is not as creative as Big Ben. my point is yes he is accurate and very good but a 95 is too much, players do what they do because of the identity of their team not godly abilities that a madden 95 represent.

[SwayGod53]

Quote: Originally Posted by seriousluboy83

well it is....what it is (in your eyes)....donny said at most 50 wasnt completely accurate tho....perk that list up brah....17 is way too slim

He didn't say at most he said right now there were about 50.