How would you rate your team in Madden 10?

[hmoob]

Wow, the ratings have changed since I've played (Madden 05, NFL 2K5). Back then most teams had (the exceptions were the top teams only):

1-3 90+
2-5 80+
And the rest were 79 and below.

I used to be excited if I got myself a player in the 70's.

People are too agressive with the ratings. Everyone seems overrated.

[CapnKill]

Quote: Originally Posted by hmoob

Wow, the ratings have changed since I've played (Madden 05, NFL 2K5). Back then most teams had (the exceptions were the top teams only): 1-3 90+ 2-5 80+ And the rest were 79 and below. I used to be excited if I got myself a player in the 70's. People are too agressive with the ratings. Everyone seems overrated.

We're just going by past Maddens, at least I was... M10 is supposed to be more like what you've described.

[TheSaint92]

Quote: Originally Posted by The Bringer

Bears Qb Cutler 92 RB Forte 90 FB Mckie 74 WR Hester 83 WR Bennet 78 TE Olsen 86 TE Clark 84 LT Pace 89 LG Omiyale 82 C Kreutz 90 RG Garza 85 RT Williams 85 K Gould 92 p Maynard 86 Defense DE Brown 85 DE Ogunleye 86 DT Harris 90 DT Adams 82 LB Briggs 93 LB Urlacher 91 LB Hillenmyer 82 CB Tillman 87 CB Vasher 86 S Payne 84 S Bullocks 84 Go Bears

What the hell?! As a Saints fan let me tell you HE SUCKS!!! He didn't even start for most of last season until KK went down and on the last roster update he was rated 78 (or 79).

[wordtobigbird]

Quote: Originally Posted by CapnKill

Possibly, but all were in the 70s. Well Jenkins is one of the bets NTs in the game. I'll go 95 but lower than that I don't think so. And why are you comparing K. Jenkins who is a DT with a HB and a QB? Are you suggesting that because Jenkins is a DT he can't possibly be 97 OVR?

it has nothing to do with his position, hes just not THAT good.

you think jenkins is comparable to the top 10-15 players in the league? not even close.

haynesworth could be a 95.. but not that odod

[CapnKill]

Quote: Originally Posted by wordtobigbird

it has nothing to do with his position, hes just not THAT good. you think jenkins is comparable to the top 10-15 players in the league? not even close. haynesworth could be a 95.. but not that odod

I'd say Haynesworth should be about 98. I'm saying that they are the best at their positions... That's like saying a FB shouldn't be a 99 because he's just a FB.

When Jenkins was healthy last year he was a HUGE force in the middle... the guy was a monster.

[XSafety20]

Not sure if anyone has rated Eagles players yet but...

Offense:
QB-McNabb-88
HB-Westbrook-93
FB-Weaver-Not sure, joined team during offseason and I'm not familiar with him
WR-D. Jackson-87
WR-Curtis-82
WR-Avant-75
TE-Celek-78
LT-Peters-90
LG-Herremans-86
C-J. Jackson-87
RG-St. Andrews-90
RT-Sh. Andrews-85

Defense:
RDE-J. Parker-83
DT-Bunkley-85
DT-Patterson-85
LDE-T. Cole-92
SLB-Gocong-81
MLB-Bradley-80
WLB-Jordan-78
CB-Samuel-91
CB-Brown-87
CB-Hanson-80
FS-Demps-79
SS-Mikell-81

Special Teams:
K-Akers-84
P-Rocca-76

I tried to be as unbiased as I can...

[I Peench]

New York Giants

QB - Eli Manning - 87
RB - Brandon Jacons - 92
FB - Madison Hedgecock - 84
WR - Dominik Hixon - 76
WR - Steve Smith - 80
WR - Braylon Edwards - 90 (wishful thinking!)
TE - Kevin Boss - 78
LT - David Diehl - 88
LG - Rich Seubert - 83
C - Shaun O'Hara - 90
RG - Chris Snee - 95
RT - Kareem McKenzie - 85
arguably the best OL in football

RE - Osi Umenyiora - 96
DT - Fred Robbins - 89
DT - Chris Canty - 84
LE - Justin Tuck - 93
WLB- Michael Boley - 79 (will thrive in this scheme)
MLB - Antonio Pierce - 80 (definately lost a step last year)
SLB - Danny Clark - 75
CB - Corey Webster - 84
FS - Kenny Phillips - 78
SS - Michael Johnson - 77
CB - Aaron Ross - 81

[pf8363]

Quote: Originally Posted by masterkembo

LMAO @ 95 for Peters. Just because he's one of the highest paid tackles, doesn't make him one of the best. Most sacks allowed for a LT in the NFL last year. Even disregarding that stat, (which is debateable at best), the guy was a turnstile last year and not much better in 2007 - his best year was 06, been downhill since then. EaglesFan17 had a much more realistic number, and I think he's still too high - 85ish would be my assessment. I've watched every game in his career BTW.

yea the fact that he made the pro bowl last year was the biggest laugh ive had in a while. he was just horrible last year and he is a cancer. all he cares about is his paycheck and imo was a one year wonder. 07 was his only good year. listen eagles fans theres a reason wh he wasnt drafted. donovan mcnabb will be hurtin this year