No Cap on players ratings! (Madden or NCAA)

[Maelstrom-XIII]

Quote: Originally Posted by da ThRONe

There are ways to seperate great students from elite students from geniuses!

...but how do you separate great players from elite players from football geniuses (other than spygate accusations? ) Making elite players have ratings between 100-200 doesn't add anything that stretching ratings properly wouldn't...

[Kingspadee]

Quote: Originally Posted by da ThRONe

There are ways to seperate great students from elite students from geniuses!

Exactly. Thanks. You just proved my point. You can have the CAP and STILL know the students from the elites and the geniuses. Thanks - can this be closed now?

[kcarr]

Quote: Originally Posted by Maelstrom-XIII

I once got an A++ in school (back in the day)...did that make me an elite student? Sweet...99 Calculus Recognition, here I come!

No, that A++ is atleast 115 calculus recognition. give yourself some credit

[Kingspadee]

I think that was a clear example of self pwn

[da ThRONe]

Quote: Originally Posted by Maelstrom-XIII

...but how do you separate great players from elite players from football geniuses (other than spygate accusations? ) Making elite players have ratings between 100-200 doesn't add anything that stretching ratings properly wouldn't...

We dont know yet ,but i agree thats the purpose. I just dislike having an cap for all player to be based on. Having a player get to 99 and thats it he cant improve one bit no matter what.

[da ThRONe]

Quote: Originally Posted by Kingspadee

Exactly. Thanks. You just proved my point. You can have the CAP and STILL know the students from the elites and the geniuses. Thanks - can this be closed now?

OK well you can stop posting in this thread whenever you like. I think this is something to think about(clearly I started this thread). But just because we cap students with GPA's dont make it right. And just because Madden cap its player doesnt mean it's whats best for the game.