OFFICIAL PLAYER RATINGS FOR M10!!

[ry8100]

Quote: Originally Posted by Krodis

You're a towel.

LOL!

[GoGiaNTS25]

Quote: Originally Posted by Big_Mig_11

From you avatar I cant believe you're hating on Frankie!! Stats are so misleading in the NFL and especially when it comes to videogame rating. I dont agree with D Williams being so high, but Gore IS a better RB than Jacobs is IMO. He ran behind arguabley the best O-Line in football compared to one hat gave up 55 sacks. Frank is faster, runs just as hard (maybe harder given his 5'9 frame), and is a threat in the passing game. Led the team in receptions. Thats why Gore is rated higher

jacobs gets no love

frank gore is good but i think jacobs should at least be in the top ten... call me a homer but i dont think any man that has brought him down would say he's not a house.

EDIT: nvm peterson is #1 :P

[xxjgbxx]

Quote: Originally Posted by Krodis

For the same reason that Brad Johnson isn't better than Pennington or Schaub?

how are you going to compare brad johnson to eli manning, brad johnson is like 37 now and eli is in his prime and is 2 seasons removed from a SB win over the infamous patriots


last season eli ranked in the top 3 in drops so quit hating on eli

[Krodis]

Quote: Originally Posted by xxjgbxx

how are you going to compare brad johnson to eli manning, brad johnson is like 37 now and eli is in his prime and is 2 seasons removed from a SB win over the infamous patriots last season eli ranked in the top 3 in drops so quit hating on eli

Ok, then for the same reason Ben Roethlisberger isn't better than Drew Brees.

Happy with that comparison?

[ry8100]

Quote: Originally Posted by g2thecore

What?

[Big_Mig_11]

Quote: Originally Posted by Krodis

Why not?

Well I believe he really benefited from the 2 back system IMO. Dont get me wrong, he's a great player, but take into account EVERYTHING a rb must do. Run, block, and pass. I rather have portis. Now I've only see a few panther games last year so I really should of not said anything. But he is in the top ten, just not 3rd or 4th overall.But his rating hasent been released so my thought may change. In the old rating philosophy he would probably be a 97 or something after a breakout year, but I would rate him in the low 90's. Im sure they gave him a fair rating

[83evans]

Lynch was a top 7 RB the last 2 yrs in a horrible OL and hes not even top 10?

[Big_Mig_11]

Quote: Originally Posted by GoGiaNTS25

jacobs gets no love frank gore is good but i think jacobs should at least be in the top ten... call me a homer but i dont think any man that has brought him down would say he's not a house. EDIT: nvm peterson is #1 :P

No you are correct. He should be in the top ten. You are not a homer. Call ME a homer, but I just don't think he is a better RB than Gore...haha