OFFICIAL PLAYER RATINGS FOR M10!!

[The_NJ_Giant]

call me a homer but i am a football fan 1st. so with that said how is mcnabb and romo rated higher than eli. IMO decision making and clutch factor should way in a lil more. if they did romo would be #10 as he chokes under pressure and donovan around 6 0r 7 as he seems to jus fail in a large spot like we seen with his poor throws in arizona. didnt Eli get a superbowl MVP . isnt he better in the clutch , which is really, jus because his arm is stronger and makes a few plays with his feet why big ben is viewed so high in many ppls eyes

[MrSkagTrendy]

I can't believe how low Brandon Jacobs is! He should at least be 91!

[iCebErgSLiM369]

Eli Manning isn't as accurate. That's why he isn't rated as high as Romo. Even though I personally would take him over Romo any day.

[kcarr]

Quote: Originally Posted by Derrville

Barbers stats before his injury: 838 ruyds 353 reyds 9 tds 1191 total yards. In 11 games. Hmmmmmmmmm.....

I still just don't see giving a 91 overall to a back who has never rushed for 1000 yards and is coming off of a season where he averaged 3.7 per carry. Sure, he was kinda banged up but until he proves he can be that elite back he should not be rated as such.

Also, they have him against guys who are proven starters who had better years than him least year (thoman jones, jacobs) and ahead of players who put up better numbers in worse situations(forte, slaton, chris johnson, kevin smith).

[Simonnova]

Barber should be in high 80s (OVR rating), but not 90s. His trucking should be in the high 90s though...

[tonedeaf]

Quote: Originally Posted by NOBLE

Awww, I thought the ratings would be lower.

no they are good. what we saw were just the elite players. the average players and bad players will be much lower. You have to give the elite players high ratings so you actually know your using them. i think the rating system will be much much better this year and you will realize you are controlling elite players.