Where will the most realistic gameplay be found? All Pro or All Madden?

[PGaither84]

Quote: Originally Posted by JeriousNorwood

All-Madden is the most realistic on '09 versus the CPU. All-Pro is more realistic against another human. All-Pro is a joke in '09 against the CPU. It's too easy to use stick skills to crush the CPU.

That's it 100%. The thing is, stick skills should not out-weigh football knowledge and execution. too many timesi see people with stick skillz try and show off a handful of plays they have perfected and when they play someone who know how to stop their garbage and they have to resort to new tricks and scheme, they fail horribly. That is why I said that All-Pro is the only sim way to play. If you are a stick guy, then All-Madden because it challenges your stick skillz over your knowledge of the game. On All-Madden you can throw to wide open players and hit open runing lanes an the computer will make you drop passes and cause blockers to just stop blocking, etc. Defenders missing multiple tackles on 3rd and long just so the computer can convert the drive on a comeback.