What's up with the fumble pile ups?

[MattIntellect]

Quote: Originally Posted by the drewster

I agree that the dev team has really paid attention to details this year with all the new equipment, dropbacks, ect... But, I don't see how the fumble pileups have to do with pro tak when it is the same cut scene with different players, the pile ups will really lose its quality after a few times because it isn't dynamic at all.

Well, Madden 10 doesn't have dynamic tackling so that's probably why it's not evident in the fumble pile-ups. I understand why a lot of people (including myself) are upset, but unfortunately we'll have to take what we get. At least multiple people can add on to the pile, maybe they just have the same jump animation.

[the drewster]

Quote: Originally Posted by MattIntellect

Well, Madden 10 doesn't have dynamic tackling so that's probably why it's not evident in the fumble pile-ups. I understand why a lot of people (including myself) are upset, but unfortunately we'll have to take what we get. At least multiple people can add on to the pile, maybe they just have the same jump animation.

by "dynamic" i meant pro tak or the adding on of players to a tackle (which madden does have). I envisioned a pile of players adding on just like players adding on to the tackle with pro tak. Obviously this isn't the case i honestly don't see how pro tak is used in the fumble pile ups.

[clevelandsfinest]

I hope if a guy fumbles down field with like only 3 guys around they don't have all these guys pile up who shouldn't even be close to that part of the field.

[MattIntellect]

Quote: Originally Posted by the drewster

by "dynamic" i meant pro tak or the adding on of players to a tackle (which madden does have). I envisioned a pile of players adding on just like players adding on to the tackle with pro tak. Obviously this isn't the case i honestly don't see how pro tak is used in the fumble pile ups.

Pro-Tak is used so that an actual pile-up will occur with multiple people. There was never anything said about it being different every time, but at least multiple people (up to 9) can jump into the pile-up.

[wheelman990]

Quote: Originally Posted by MattIntellect

Pro-Tak is used so that an actual pile-up will occur with multiple people. There was never anything said about it being different every time, but at least multiple people (up to 9) can jump into the pile-up.

I know it would never be allowed, but could you imagine if they had the cut scene or in game annimations for players pulling out other team players from the pile(drag by the foot,lol) and even better a fight now and then,lol. Maybe thats to realistic!!

Better yet if you could control the player and have a drag out button to grab and pull players. That could actually be a fun "mini game" lol. The more you pull out, the better chance your team can recover!

[Jimixiii]

i'm not sure why it had to be cutscene but i guess...should've just been apart of the in-game experience instead of a manufactured cutscene everytime.

[wheelman990]

Quote: Originally Posted by Jimixiii

i'm not sure why it had to be cutscene but i guess...should've just been apart of the in-game experience instead of a manufactured cutscene everytime.

Right on, Im right with you on this one.

[Pared]

Quote: Originally Posted by clevelandsfinest

I hope if a guy fumbles down field with like only 3 guys around they don't have all these guys pile up who shouldn't even be close to that part of the field.

I think THIS is a valid concern. I would hope they account for this.

But I honestly don't see the same pile-up cutscene being played that big of an issue. They could have either put it in next year with a few different ones and not put it in this year... or put the one they did in this year with hope for more next year.

I'll take one this year for $500, Alex.