Any with NCAA 10 prefer that gameplay to Madden 2010?

[manny2k8]

I haven't had a chance to play the demo but have been really enjoying the new NCAA this year. I took last year off so this is a really good and great playing game of football.

Is Madden far better gameplay wise or is it a pretty miniscule difference?

[raiders81tim]

Quote: Originally Posted by manny2k8

I haven't had a chance to play the demo but have been really enjoying the new NCAA this year. I took last year off so this is a really good and great playing game of football. Is Madden far better gameplay wise or is it a pretty miniscule difference?

NCAA is just as bad as Madden 09. Doesn't even begin to compare to Madden 10 imo.

[milehighmagic303]

Quote: Originally Posted by raiders81tim

NCAA is just as bad as Madden 09. Doesn't even begin to compare to Madden 10 imo.

NCAA is not as bad as Madden 09...
The Madden gameplay has improved to me and i feel it may be better than NCAA,but I'll have to wait for release before I can actually tell

[carnalnirvana]

Quote: Originally Posted by raiders81tim

NCAA is just as bad as Madden 09. Doesn't even begin to compare to Madden 10 imo.

he does not have the game............

you cant compare a demo to a game out already too early to tell. Basically one game is going to be slower than the other.

its gonna be hard to get an unbiased answer here since most here are blind loyalists, just look at his comments...........

[Outkizast]

Quote: Originally Posted by raiders81tim

NCAA is just as bad as Madden 09. Doesn't even begin to compare to Madden 10 imo.

I think you're on something....( crack probably..)

anyways NCAA's gameplay is WAY better than Madden 09... it doesn't even begin to compare... Having played Ncaa10 AND both Madden demos... It's kind of hard to compare them... I feel like I had more control in NCAA... but with Madden being slowed down and the momentum that they gave the players... it feels almost like a COMPLETELY different game IMO... I like both.... But I feel like I have to rely on some of my cpu defenders a bit more in madden....

[raiders81tim]

How can you defend crap like NCAA 10? Only good thing about the game is they added over the shoulder catches. Everything else as far as gameplay goes is garbage.

[milehighmagic303]

Quote: Originally Posted by raiders81tim

How can you defend crap like NCAA 10? Only good thing about the game is they added over the shoulder catches. Everything else as far as gameplay goes is garbage.

Have you actually played NCAA 10? Its not as bad as you're making it out to be

[zpq12]

I had been playing my brother's copy of NCAA and was pretty sold on it, but after playing the Madden 10 demo I'm not sure I could go back.