Would you guys be surprised if NCAA ends up being the better of the 2?

[The_Balm]

YES!!!!

[Sausage]

I have rented and played NCAA often since its release and patch, and for -->me<-- it is a no contest win for Madden. After playing the 5 min GS demo I can't even go back and trust me I have tried several times. Madden in my opinion feels leaps and bounds better than 09' and better than NCAA 10.

I do no when College football is on I will pop NCAA in for some "play now" matches, but majority of my time will be spent on Madden 10 and Fight Night (another excellent game for boxing fans).

[carnalnirvana]

i love football games period....

i have bought madden and got ncaa as a rental to compliment madden with draft classes and on and off play especially if i got hyped from a good game i saw

but this year, madden is gonna compliment my ncaa 10.

ncaa 10 has loads of issues, but i know ( and dont ask me how i do) but i know madden's gameplay will not be what I am looking for out of an nfl game....

see ncaa gets a pass because its kids who do anything they want for 2 or 3 years,

nfl each team has a tradition that i think madden does not capture, when i play the 5 minute demo i dont see "steeler's football" when i played the cards i was not afraid of that offense and please dont tell me " its a demo" because it it was meant to show me NOTHING of the final product why did they tell me download it as a representation of MADDEN 10.

if you cant capture steeler football for a demo then you dont have it in the final product, this demo is a build of the game now if the FOUNDATION is not solid or Accurate then how can the game be accurate.

[SageInfinite]

I enjoy the Madden demo more than the NCAA retail.

[cowboys249]

NOT ALL ALL! MADDEN IS WAYY BETTER!

[TombSong]

Quote: Originally Posted by Dmacho

Play online, you'll see that it's trash.

LOL, yes. I have posted a few of my online episodes. Online is gonna tell on both games. I am saying just from my time spent with both, NCAA and the Madden demo play alot alike.

[SA1NT401]

TO Me, as well as several others, its all about GAMEPLAY. The gameplay in NCAA is VERY good. If madden is BETTER, than we have reached a HUGE leap forward.

I am LOVING NCAA especially now with sliders working....GREAT GAMES since (and i was having very good ones b4) and the M10 Demo shows alot of improvements and the new speed setting.....FAN-Friggin-Tastic.

I would be VERY shocked to say the least.

[celg35]

no way , i have played the demo of madden and it is still better than ncaa.

so its a def nooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo