I'm playing with Broncos, opinions (franchise)

[canes21]

While you may lose and have better stats, All Pro is still more realistic. Ian even stated that. It is designed where all ratings matter. On All Madden players perform better than their ratings.

[tonedeaf]

Quote: Originally Posted by canes21

While you may lose and have better stats, All Pro is still more realistic. Ian even stated that. It is designed where all ratings matter. On All Madden players perform better than their ratings.

Yeah but what would you rather have: 1)The AI playing like their real-life counter partners, but your almost never loosing or 2)the AI playing better then their real life counter partners, but the stats and your record look more realistic?

I pick option #2. However, i might be going on all pro this year, because the ratings actually matter in this game unlike previous maddens. With the rating system tweaked, it should be very realistic. I always use to play on all madden in 09 because i almost never lost on all pro and it didnt even matter what team i was using.

This year, if im the lions and im playing the patriots, i bet i will get blown out on all pro. So my point is, with the rating system overhaul, it should make it so all pro is harder then it ever was which will make it very realistic.

IMO, its weird how they evaluate the rating system based on the diffuculty level. So i guess pro makes the players play worse then their ratings and on rookie, they play a lot worse then their ratings. I think all madden should be the more realistic difficulty, but thats just my opinion.

[MattieShoes]

If you put it on all-pro and you're used to playing on pro, you'll struggle for a couple games and then all-pro will be beatable, and by the end of the first season it'll seem too easy.

One alternative to all-madden is custom with the sliders turned up past all-pro... That supposedly stops the CPU from knowing your play calls like it does on all-madden.

[adamgod8]

Quote: Originally Posted by tonedeaf

Its true for me. If im never loosing on all pro, then thats not realistic at all. I never said it was realistic for everyone, i said it was for me and maybe him. On all madden, i find myself actually loosing multiple games a season which is realistic. And i have stats that fit the players better then they would on all pro. And, i did tell him to put it on all pro. I never told him to put it on all madden. When i said "if i were you i would put it on all madden", i was stating what i would do, not what he should do.

if you weren't telling him what to do you should have said "if I were me"

[kehlis]

Quote: Originally Posted by adamgod8

if you weren't telling him what to do you should have said "if I were me"

Unless I'm missing something the OP was looking for suggestions.

Suggestions very often include someone describing their personal experience. Feel free to correct me if I am wrong.

[Dawkins#20]

I never stayed on all madden, it always cheated before. Might try it again although on the demo I was finding it much tougher on all pro than last year. That was partially down to it being a 1 min demo. Will see though

[MelMan1486]

Quote: Originally Posted by canes21

All Pro is the more realistic game. I say All Pro

I agree... what's the point in playing if you win every game, I'd say All-Madden but it just seems like All-Madden means that you're players ratings drop while the CPUs get a boost.