NCAA Has Set The Bar High!

[Madwolf]

I thought NCAA set the bar pretty low actually. The gameplay improvement was marginal at best.

[Potatoes002]

Im already bored with ncaa, it feels like the same game every year.

[jWILL253]

How an arcadish, glitchy downgrade from last year set the bar for an NFL sim is beyond me.

It's threads like these that give 2K fanboys fuel to their fire...

[KANE699]

Quote: Originally Posted by Deegeezy

Disagree. Why can't a person enjoy an easy to play game while also being a fan of the hardcore genre of Madden? The only games I have played NCAA is with my son and we enjoy it for what it is, a video game. But you better believe that once I fire up my Madden chise, it will be all about sim.

As long as you admit NCAA is a kids game then we can move forward.

Fact of the matter is madden is shooting for real and NCAA is shooting for casual therefore no bar can be set by a casual game.


The games should play almost damn near the same the only differences should be ratings and presentation to show a college atmosphere, the actual game of football does not change from college to the pros period, why should the games be different?

[J-Unit40]

Quote: Originally Posted by KANE699

Let me just put it out there now, if you like the ncaa gameplay, you will hate madden this year, it is by far too realistic comming from ncaa and will make you actually have to think, so if you're an ncaa fan you might wanna stick to just that game this year.

Okay. Yeah, Madden is going to be like playing chess now. Get out of here with that nonsense.

Too realistic? You really have to be kidding with this one. How is NCAA unrealistic or not "too realistic" and Madden is? Pro-TAK? A gamespeed slider? Some QB ratings?

Newsflash: These games are not going to be that much different from a gameplay vantage point. Count on it. Madden is not all that different than NCAA if you take away the presentation in Madden.

Madden will be good. I can already tell by playing the demo. However, to think it will be "too realistic" is just a blind statement.

[Gossennator]

The only thing NCAA has done for me is switch to Madden. After playing the Madden demo a couple of times, I find it hard to play NCAA.

[KANE699]

Uh you can bank on the games playing totally different and players not being able to turn 120º at the sideline and turn up field rather than having their momentum carry them out of bounds, madden will actually be like a chess match this year, you can bank on that.

Im not saying it will be the most realistic game ever, im saying realism for realism it will blow away NCAA.

[DGuinta1]

Quote: Originally Posted by Gossennator

The only thing NCAA has done for me is switch to Madden. After playing the Madden demo a couple of times, I find it hard to play NCAA.

Hah same here.