ncaa import draft rating too low?

[gator3guy]

Quote: Originally Posted by ScriptOhio

Unplayable?? Because you don't like one guys speed rating? Dude you got issues, draft someone else! That's why they have scouting, and yes the ratings and ages change if you load the same class 2 seasons in a row.

That's not the point dude. It shouldn't be like that. The guy runs a 4.3. He is successful because he has that speed. He goes from 95 speed in NCAA to 83 in Madden. They completely changed his playing style. I understand they stretched out the ratings, but a -12 point differential is ridiculous. JAMAL LEWIS HAS 83 SPEED!!! Watch this video and tell me CJ Spiller runs like Jamal Lewis:



The way the system is is basically picking numbers out of a hat. Get real before you make an opinion of me.

[gator3guy]

Quote: Originally Posted by Clinton56

when Spiller is drafted do you all think hell have elite NFL speed?maybe the drop in speed reflects how much faster the pro game is than college.I prfer lower rated rookies than too many 90+ rookies

I dont want high overall players, but you should not take away a player's athleticism (speed, agility, acceleration, jumping). If a guy runs a 4.4 in college he'll run a 4.4 in the NFL.

[Fu Man Ching]

Quote: Originally Posted by gator3guy

I dont want high overall players, but you should not take away a player's athleticism (speed, agility, acceleration, jumping). If a guy runs a 4.4 in college he'll run a 4.4 in the NFL.

I agree. Better than last year but still not right.

[uraz3r0]

Quote: Originally Posted by gator3guy

I dont want high overall players, but you should not take away a player's athleticism (speed, agility, acceleration, jumping). If a guy runs a 4.4 in college he'll run a 4.4 in the NFL.

I just wanna say that it's ok for a guy's speed to go down a little too, but yeah in CJ's case that stinks.

[Dbrentonbuck]

I really wish a couple more people would post some imported draft classes. I thought the first one that was posted (a couple weeks ago) looked great. Now the OP says they aren't. I would like to see a few more if anyone would be so kind, it is one of the things I would base my decision on buying this game on.

[gator3guy]

Quote: Originally Posted by uraz3r0

I just wanna say that it's ok for a guy's speed to go down a little too, but yeah in CJ's case that stinks.

Yea of course it's going to go down with the stretch in the ratings. But a 95 speed in NCAA should be 92-93 speed in madden.

[Dbrentonbuck]

one thing I would also ask is for the OP to go into NCAA and look at Spiller and see what kind of back he is rated as (Speed, Balanced, Power). I wonder if this has anything to do with it.

[cam780]

Quote: Originally Posted by Scoop 24

the overall ratings are ok.. its the attribute ratings that bug me. guy like CJ spiller dropping 10+ points in speed to a 83? Since when do guys get slower just because they go to the NFL.

That might be a combination of several things such as the stretched ratings and don't forget its a comparison against NFL talent not a pure measure of skill / talent. And the other thing is the speed maybe an issue that is fixed if you reimport.