I've been playing Madden 10 since Friday in hopes of getting the most glaring issues out of the way. Before I start, i'll say that Madden 09 was by far the WORST excuse for a football game i've ever played. It was not bad, it was atrocious and for the first time in my life I returned a FOOTBALL (my favorite sport) GAME within 2 weeks of purchase. That said, it is a complete 180 turn for the series as Madden 10 is simply put, close to the best football game i've ever played. VERY CLOSE.
Technical Issues:
Replays not triggering - After certan situations i.e. Turner with a big run, the screen with fade in with a cool EA logo as if a replay is suppose to trigger, yet it doesn't.
Strafing issues - Im not sure what causes this, but it first became an issue in NCAA 08. I notice that while playing as a FS/MLB/CB, when I turn left or right (coming out of a straf into a full sprint to keep up with the reciever as he cuts) my man completely losses speed. Almost as if jogging.
DB Responsiveness - On a few rare occasions i've noticed that my DB will not react to me pressing either "swat" or "intercept" button. Its as if he gets caught up in the wrong animation. i.e. I had a SS and a CB covering Eagles WR Maclin. The SS had the outside coverage, my CB had the inside coverage (it was perfect coverage on the WR). As the ball was thrown, I pressed "intercept" but the defender (instead of jumping) did a funky arm swat behind his back no where close to the play.
QB Style Stance - I can only change the style, which by default changes the stance... But I cannot change both is this by design? i.e. No Peyton Manning Style with Romo stance.
Hair - Is there a reason we cannot create players with long hair or dreads? This was definatly included in Madden 07 and 08. You guys worked hard to put in a Madden store, those efforts could have gone to giving the user more customization options in regaurds to appearance... We are VERY limited in selecting player faces...
Those are all i've seen so far, and none of which are anywhere NEAR a game-breaker. Madden 10 is awesome.
Few Rants:
Locomotion has to include different running styles for every position on the field next year... it'll make a large difference.
Although throwing looks pretty decent, it still has a semi-cartoonish flare to it, i'd look to see this improved upon next year in great detail...
Mike Vick needs to be a Free Agents - complete with his AWESOME throwing motion