What would you rate Madden NFL 10 so far?

[carterjt47]

I would give it a 10,but its the online cheating that pisses me off,wait a few days and youll start to see the cheesers/chaters in the online play......I give it a 9

[bkrich83]

Quote: Originally Posted by bukktown

Its finally fun again.

\

To me that's the most important thing.

[joec63]

I would give it an 8.5 , room for improvement but fun. Annoyances from another post:

Some things that drive me mad are the fluttering pass when the QB gets hit. Happens too frequent. The missed tackles, I know the Browns suck but come on. also, the breaking of tackles when I have the guy dead to rights.

[Jump]

Madden 09 - 5.0
Madden 10 - 7.5

It's playable and can be fun, but I can't pretend that I don't see the fundamental flaws.

[chainsaw4099]

8.5 very good game

[wheelman990]

To many people think of a 8 rating as a bad score. Thats a excellent score! There are tons of "good games" that dont even get that rating. Id give Madden 2010 between a 7.5-8. Id rate Madden 09 about a 5. A very bad attempt at a football game.

In all fairness 2010 is a improvement. But its not near the level of most 8.5+ rated games. MLB the show got a 9. Is Madden really that close, not to me. I still compare Madden to "the other game" which is getting old, but true.

[bkrich83]

Quote: Originally Posted by wheelman990

To many people think of a 8 rating as a bad score. Thats a excellent score! There are tons of "good games" that dont even get that rating. Id give Madden 2010 between a 7.5-8. Id rate Madden 09 about a 5. A very bad attempt at a football game. In all fairness 2010 is a improvement. But its not near the level of most 8.5+ rated games. MLB the show got a 9. Is Madden really that close, not to me. I still compare Madden to "the other game" which is getting old, but true.

You say you give m10 a 7.5-8 but you voted a 5-6.9.

Which is it?

[countryboy]

8.5. Game is very solid.