|
Quote: |
|
|
|
|
Originally Posted by kingkilla56 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
My bad for fabricating? lol
Yeah some ratings should be progressed based on performance like awareness(like that means something),accuracy(some guys just get it in the pros), even things like stiff arm and juke and truck(aka the R stick). Some should not be, speed, injury,height lol. I understand why you would say a rookie rated 72 ovr runs for 1200 but he is still 72 ovr. But doesn't experience count for anything? A player learns the speed of the game how to react etc etc as he plays, not that madden can represent that(yet). Tom Brady has an exceptionaly strong arm but he honestly didn't come out of college with that arm, and may not have had it to its peak when he won the first superbowl. Said gem draft pick came in as a scrub, showed up to play, won the job and continued to play, and know he is an amazing player(as much as I hate him).
|
|
|
|
|
|
ok i just wanted to say that speed rating can be effected by weight/athletism/muscle tone. as well as training maybe not effect it by much but still that has to be taken into account a lot of players loose or gain 5-25 pounds in a offseason normally to help increase there speed/quickness/agility(or if there gaining weight for more powers/strenght/break tackls) this is rating wise. however doing so has its negatives. loosing weight takes away trucking/strength/blocking. while gaining weights negatives are speed/agility/elusiveness etc
this should be concidered in madden but its not.
as for you guys saying that player statistics doesnt help there progression (or madden rating) ill just use a example
lets look at kurt warner
madden 08 rating - 80 age:36
nfl 07-08 stats
G Att Comp Pct Att/G Yds Avg Yds/G TD TD% Int Int% Lng 20+
14 451 281 62.3 32.2 3,417 7.6 244.1 27 6.0 17 3.8 62 44 5 20
40+ Sck SckY Rate
5 20 140 89.8
--------------------------------------------------------------
madden 09 rating - 85 age:37 (+5 increase)
nfl 08-09 stats
G Att Comp Pct Att/G Yds Avg Yds/G TD TD% Int Int% Lng 20+
16 598 401 67.1 37.4 4,583 7.7 286.4 30 5.0 14 2.3 79T 50
40+ Sck SckY Rate
79T 50 12 26 182 96.9
--------------------------------------------------------------
madden 10 rating = 95! age:38!
soo let me get this straight kurt warner who is 37 years old in the 08 09 season his great season he had and playoff's did not have anything to do with his overall rating going up +10 in madden 10?
maybe some other things should be included like playoff play and talent around a player (warner has 2 pro bowl receivers to throw to) but in general there is no other contributing factor of why his rating went up +10 in one year at that age? gimme a break guys