Which Trade Would You Pick?

[TeamBuilder]

I'm in a Chargers franchise and I have a deal in place where I can make either of these two trades...

Titans
HB Chris Johnson (88 OVR)
FS Michael Griffin (95 OVR)
RT David Stewart (92 OVR)

or

Panthers
MLB Jon Beason (92 OVR)
RT Jeff Otah (86 OVR)
HB Jonathan Stewart (85 OVR)


I don't know which trade to make. I consider both RT's to be a wash, so what it really comes down to is Johnson/Griffin vs. Stewart/Beason.

Beason > Griffin because he's a middle linebacker and more important than a safety. But Johnson > Stewart with his 99 speed and ridiculous game breaking ability.

Which trade would you pick?

[RedZoneD25]

Id go with titans(secondary>lb corps to me) but to be honest its impossible to tell without you saying what youre giving up in return..

[TeamBuilder]

Giving up LE Shaun Philips (99 OVR) 2nd, and a 3rd.

[nickohrn]

Definitely Titans. Without a doubt.

[sammcculloch]

titans
by your second year chris johnson will be 95 or 96

[Insomniac33]

Depends if u want speed Titans. If u want power Panthers. i would go with Titans just cause Charger need a good safety, u can get a MLB in FA.

[Valdarez]

I'd take the Titans trade, but I'm a Texas fan. I'd do it for Griffin alone.

[murdamann10]

I'd go with the panthers. Otah is a great young player. So is beason, and so is Stewart. yea johnson might be better than stewart but you already got sproles if your using the chargers, and stewart can be a great compliment.