Question about draft classes...

[RavensFan2k3]

Which draft classes are more realistic and do you guys prefer to use: NCAA draft classes or madden generated draft classes? i love using ncaa draft classes, but i dont like knowing who is going to be good before i draft them. what do you guys prefer?

[Cantgetright69]

Quote: Originally Posted by RavensFan2k3

Which draft classes are more realistic and do you guys prefer to use: NCAA draft classes or madden generated draft classes? i love using ncaa draft classes, but i dont like knowing who is going to be good before i draft them. what do you guys prefer?

Well after awhile the madden generated ones, the good players in it will be well known so its moot point. But trying out the madden ones wont hurt.

[Dianwei32]

It depends. Inititally I rented NCAA and just simmed 4 seasons, knowing nothing about college football. Some guys came out well (Sam Bradford, LaGarrette Blount, N. Suh), but a lot of guys who have done really well this year and are projected to do well in the NFL came out poorly (Toby Gerhart, Mark Ingram, Ryan Mallett, Jimmy Clausen, Eric Berry, and more) so I tended to use the Madden classes more since my draft classes weren't very good.

However, I recently rented NCAA again and have spent the last week messing with roster ratings and simming seasons trying to get better classes.

[ddanese1978]

Quote: Originally Posted by Dianwei32

It depends. Inititally I rented NCAA and just simmed 4 seasons, knowing nothing about college football. Some guys came out well (Sam Bradford, LaGarrette Blount, N. Suh), but a lot of guys who have done really well this year and are projected to do well in the NFL came out poorly (Toby Gerhart, Mark Ingram, Ryan Mallett, Jimmy Clausen, Eric Berry, and more) so I tended to use the Madden classes more since my draft classes weren't very good. However, I recently rented NCAA again and have spent the last week messing with roster ratings and simming seasons trying to get better classes.

I would LOVE to know how your new draft classes came out and if I can use them? I have played 14 offline franchise seasons with 3 different teams and I LOVE the NCAA classes because using real names is much cooler then computer generated fake ones. But like you said people like E.Berry, Suh, McCoy, Ingram and Gerhart are not good at all in the draft classes.

If you get some classes that are more real let me know please