Which Madden Was Best?

[teddyberrz]

From the choices of Madden 2002, Madden 2003 or Madden 2004, which had the very best gameplay on the PS2?

[goh]

2002 easy,it was great.
2003 was ok.
2004 was the biggest joke in football game history and I didn't even take it for free when I had the chance.

[teddyberrz]

C`mon guys, opinions please.

[Rishawn]

seeing that i only played 04 and on gamecube at dat im goin wit dat

[24]

i enjoyed 04 the most but madden 2002 is the best out of the three. the main reason why 2004 is not my favorite was the Atlanta Falcons factor. or the Michael Vick factor if you want. I devoted hours upon hours trying to stop the Atlanta Falcons. no matter what team i picked in 04 i could still not stop Mike Vick hurting me both ways. I would blita he shoots out of the pocket and throws a 50 yard bomb to peerless price. If he was not doing that he was avoiding every possible defender with his insane jukes and spins. i once created a team of all 99 rated players and still lost to the falcons 56-48 Vick not only passed for 400+ yards but ran for 200+. That right there is the only reason why 2002 is better because 2004 was so damn frustrating try to stop michael vick

[2Koalition]

I'd have to say none of those and go with Madden 2008 for the PS3. Best overall experience, sometimes while watching a real football game I always had the urge to look at my PS3 to see if I accidently turned it on.

Playcalling was realistic, best franchise mode in a game.