One thing I'll miss IF the Draft Classes are Randomized

[mavfan21]

DICSCLAIMER: I do want the draft class names/schools to be random. I got tired of knowing who all the studs were, it made the draft boring.

BUT, I will miss the fun we have on this site of sharing who we drafted, rating the top prospects, etc. There's many threads on here dedicated to "Okoye vs. Taylor", "Who's the best Madden Generated QB", "The best players to build your franchise around", etc. Those fun discussions all go away once (IF) the classes are randomized.

Would you support an option to turn off/on randomized names in the franchise set up menu? It might be fun to sometimes do franchises with "shared" classes.

In retrospect, what really killed the fun of Franchise drafting was the Prima Head Coach Future 50 guide and the Lokisfather guide (no offense to lokisfather, I used it and appreciated it, but after a while I regretted it).

[huskerwr38]

I will not miss the crafted draft class, because, like you said, it kills the fun of not knowing who is going to be a bust and a stud.

[Droopy03]

I don't know about you but I wasn't able to draft every player right and I had a lot of bust..... I think it is good to know who has the hype coming out of the draft.

[Vikefan24]

Non random draft classes would be a franchise killer if it wasn't for importing from NCAA..

If they fix the importing issue so the players come into Madden as they should(i.e no big drops in physical attributes) then it's a non-issue

[Vikefan24]

Quote: Originally Posted by Droopy03

I don't know about you but I wasn't able to draft every player right and I had a lot of bust..... I think it is good to know who has the hype coming out of the draft.

You can still see who has "hype".. If you see a randomly generated QB that is projected to be a top 5 pick than you can consider him "hyped"

[Droopy03]

Quote: Originally Posted by Vikefan24

You can still see who has "hype".. If you see a randomly generated QB that is projected to be a top 5 pick than you can consider him "hyped"

But that top 5 pick you cant see if he will have great potential to be great player... every player that comes into the league has there own ratings from the teams scouts.. only problem in Madden is that you can;t actually use your scouts it is kind of the games scouts that comes up with these ratings... I think it would be a lot better if you had your own teams scouts ratings and could see maybe maybe 2 or 3 espn scout ratings which you will have different opinions for each of them. And just like real life teams go off of there team scouts and not all these so call professional scouts.

that is what would make it fun becasue every team wouldn't have the same ratings on each player.

[ZoneKIller]

I think the best thing to do is NOT read the guides or tips on who is the best players in the Draft.I was tempted but I forced myself to overlook those things.

I think it would be nice to have Random names.But I liked the Classes from Madden 10 so Im sure I'll like Madden 11s too.

[DoubleIt5]

I disagree with the OP. There will still be discussions about great generated players. The difference will be one person saying Ike Tatum is the best QB, another saying Joe Pilpot, when in reality they're the same guy.