Do you think this is a fair trade?

[Bengals28]

Yeah it's not really realistic. There's no way I'd give up M. Johnson and it wouldnt make sense giving up any of those players except simpson with a pick since there 4 points better ovr. Edwards wouldnt crack my lineup at all I just want him on my team bc im a big fan of him. I'll just wait a year or 2 into franchise when he hasnt done anything.

[StreetCarp]

Including any rookies in a trade is unrealistic.