Gamespot Review is up.

[Garrett67]

8.0

http://www.gamespot.com/xbox360/spor...11/review.html

[extremeskins04]

Fair review. The only review I thought was a little far fetched was the Gametrailers review when they gave the game a 9.1 score.

I think the game is worth about an 8.5. It's not a horrible game but it's not memorable.

[Klocker]

I'd say it's going to go down as the most memorable version of this gen by far (pending M12)

although GS calls it...

Quote:

Improvements such as revamped AI, more realistic animation, and a new play-calling system make this the best Madden yet.

[myownsun]

Thanks for the heads up.

[haljordan73]

Quote: Originally Posted by extremeskins04

Fair review. The only review I thought was a little far fetched was the Gametrailers review when they gave the game a 9.1 score. I think the game is worth about an 8.5. It's not a horrible game but it's not memorable.

?
I swear I think I disagree with half the internet on the scoring issue, to me 8.5 denotes a damn good game, definitely memorable.

[BlastX21]

This is ridiculous. I dont care if he got the game last week, theres no way you can make a full, accurate review this early.

This is why the madden's and NCAA's, including the ones we criticize a ton, all get good scores. Rushed reviews.

[InsomniaKiller]

A week is more than enough time to write a fair review for any game. IGN's review seemed fair and pointed out the pros and cons of the game in a very objective manner. haven't read Gamespot's review, yet, but the score is apparently the same. I would rate the game a bit higher than that, but that's just my opinion vs. theirs. If a patch comes out that addresses the defensive AI, this game deserves higher than a 9, IMO.

[BiGTooT]

Good to see that the game got good reviews and i believe a week is more than enough to review a game.