Thinking of trading in NCAA for Madden

[UMDDogs]

Has anyone played both if so what are your thoughts on the games.

[DanSF49]

Quote: Originally Posted by UMDDogs

Has anyone played both if so what are your thoughts on the games.

My advice is don't do it. Keep NCAA which is the best it has ever been and go pick up Backbreaker, then download some NFL Rosters and enjoy your NFL game for this year. I really wanted to love Madden this year but I couldn't be more disappointed.

[roadman]

Oh, oh, no sliders from Dan.

[Chivs]

I was actually thinking of doing the opposite haha.
Saw Madden for a cheap price so I thought why not pick it up. Have only played it for about an hour so I can't really say much about it but I've just got this feeling of missing out on what NCAA has to offer.
Could be the Dynasty, could be the presentation/college atmosphere.... I dunno.
Maybe it's just because I chose Madden that I'm feeling I'm missing out, and I would feel the same way if I picked NCAA over Madden.

Well that probably confused you even more haha sorry.

[ryan36]

...we've got all sorts of impressions, and the football-other thread for direct comparisons...we've also closed all the other threads that ask this here. So closed