A.Brooks 86 Vick & McNabb 84 Harrington 85 Ramsey 84 THA

[TedTurner]

WTF

Comp%
Aaron Brooks
55.3 Career
53.6

Donovan McNabb
56.9 Career
58.4 limited action would be lower if he didn't play hurt
Harrington
50

P.Ramsey
51.5

Michael Vick
52.6 Career
54.9

Dante (81 THA)
Career 62.3

Pennington (96 THA)
68.9% last year but, come on its 1 year and a lot of dink and dunk and then let Coles run

I have issues with probaly %75 of QB THA ratings

[Brett1227]

Have you seen Pennington play? I think he maybe misfired on like 10 passes the entire season. Look at the INT numbers for all those people, because there is more than just completion percentage.

[JohnDoe8865]

I don't know, Brooks throws plenty of picks.

[JStro]

Didn't you already make a Ratings Complaint Thread?

[RobUofM]

It's Madden 2004. It's not Strat-O-Matic, so they don't have to make the ratings identical to what the player did last year. For example Harrington should have a much better year so their anticapating that.

[Colwyn33]

Plus where are you getting your rankings from anyway? I ahve the strategy guide in front of me and they'r ejust...all....WRONG.....
Brooks is an 89, Vick is a 95, McNabb is a 95. Harrington is a 79, Ramsey is a 76, Pennington is an 88, and of course Gannon is a 97 )just had to add that in there gleefully)

[CheckMate]

The Prima Guide's ratings are wrong. The guys at Football Gaming compared the ratings in the guide and the ratings on the xbox/pc.

[Programmed2Kill]

man, your ratings tantrums your pulling is getting tired. and like somebody else said, didn't you make your own Ratings Rant thread??? just put all this in there. geez.