I disagree with the OP. Taken the spin move out of Madden is like taking the block button out of Boxing or fighting games in general, because after all, no one blocks hits that much. lol.
How about just dealing with it, by getting your stick game up. It has its uses. Next thread will be "Unrealistic Hitstick or Truckstick; let's get rid of it too" Madden is a video and not real. If you want real, organize a real game and prohibit the spin. J/k. Play the game and have fun with it.