Ratings and Roster announcement "near future"

[Broncos86]

According to Donny Moore (https://twitter.com/#!/donny_moore) we'll be seeing some "Exciting roster & rating announcements coming soon for [Madden12]."

With that said, I'm curious what you think the biggest upset rating will be. Who will be grotesquely overrated or underrated?

[oneamongthefence]

Any Qb under Peyton Manning is underrated. Cam Newton will be overrated.

[Bolt4Life24]

Quote: Originally Posted by Broncos86

According to Donny Moore we'll be seeing some "Exciting roster & rating announcements coming soon for [Madden12]." With that said, I'm curious what you think the biggest upset rating will be. Who will be grotesquely overrated or underrated?

I think Vick will be very over rated. I think he'll be around 95 overall.

Raiders as usual won't be "overall" stat over rated, but just like last year they will have one of the best offenses in the game because speed kills.

[Broncos86]

Quote: Originally Posted by Bolt4Life24

I think Vick will be very over rated. I think he'll be around 95 overall. Raiders as usual won't be "overall" stat over rated, but just like last year they will have one of the best offenses in the game because speed kills.

Vick is a 90, according to one of the EA videos. I certainly agree with Albert in that Newton is going to be overrated. I think Jahvid Best will be overrated.

[suthrnthug]

If I had to pick a player who will be overrated it might be Peyton Hillis. I think they might up his ratings slightly because he is this year's cover. For underrated, maybe Colts WR Reggie Wayne. I always felt the game never gave him his just due especially his speed rating. I think it was 89 in Madden 10. I didn't buy 11 so maybe they changed last year. That's my two cents!

[Madwolf]

Overrated: Mike Vick

Underrated: Charles Johnson

[krc1130]

Overrated: Cam Newton - They'll probably give him an 80 ovr rating, but he really should be a 71-73 with a potential of 99; however, EA probably doesn't want to rate the top pick lower than the fourteenth pick.

Underrated: Calvin Johnson - I think I saw his rating was a 93 on the EA video that showed Vick as a 90. 93 is a high rating, but Johnson is possibly the most physically talented WR in the NFL. He deserves a 97-98 rating.

[FlyEaglesFly3]

Quote: Originally Posted by Madwolf

Overrated: Mike Vick Underrated: Charles Johnson

How is a 90 OVR over-rated for Micheal Vick? If anything that'd be under-rated depending who is behind/in front of him